They Asked 422 Burglars What Made Them Walk Away. The Locks Did Not Come First.
In This Series: Fraud & Digital Security
- Nobody Updates the Router. The FBI Says Criminals Are Living in the Old Ones.
- Your Voice Is No Longer Proof That It Is You
- A Credit Freeze Blocks the Rarer Kind of Identity Theft. Here Is What Blocks the Rest.
- Four Points Identify You. That Is Why Your Location Is Worth Selling.
- The Two-Factor Code on Your Phone Will Not Stop This
- Changing Your Password Every 90 Days Made It Easier to Guess. The Standard That Started the Rule Now Says to Stop.
- Romance Scam Victims Were Better Educated Than People Who Never Fell for One. The Newest Version Never Asks for Money.
- The Same Offer Went From 11% Acceptance to 42%. Only the Buttons Changed.
Disclosure: this article contains affiliate links, marked (paid link). If you buy through one we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing and it does not change what we recommend.
Key takeaways · 11 min read
- 422 incarcerated burglars were asked directly. 62% called it spur of the moment.
- The top deterrents were occupancy, police proximity and a dog, ahead of alarms and cameras.
- Fewer than a third rated lighting, watch signs or a full mailbox as a factor.
- Only about 12% picked a lock or used a key. Nearly everyone else went through something open or forced.
Almost everything written about home security is written by people selling home security. One substantial exception is unusual enough to build an article around: researchers at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte put a questionnaire to 422 incarcerated burglars across three states, asking how they actually chose houses, how they got in, and what made them walk away.
Two findings reorganise the standard advice. 62% described their burglaries as spur of the moment rather than planned, which means that most of the time you are not being targeted, you are being noticed. The deterrent ranking is the other, and it does not put hardware at the top.
Below: what they said, what it implies about where money is worth spending, and which standard recommendations the evidence does not support.
What actually makes them leave
Deterrents, ranked by the people being deterred
422 incarcerated burglars, three states, self-administered questionnaire.
Source: Blevins, K.R. & Kuhns, J.B., Understanding Decisions to Burglarize from the Offender’s Perspective, University of North Carolina at Charlotte Department of Criminal Justice and Criminology, sponsored by the Alarm Industry Research and Educational Foundation.
A caveat, stated plainly: the study was funded by the alarm industry’s research foundation. That is a real conflict of interest, and it is a reason to read the results carefully. Two things make it more credible. The funded product finished fourth, behind two things nobody sells, and lighting, another commercial category, performed poorly. A survey designed to flatter its sponsor would have looked different.
They are not picking your lock
The entry method holds the second surprise, and it explains why a lot of money goes on the wrong component.
How they got in
Reported entry methods.
Source: Blevins & Kuhns, UNC Charlotte burglar survey.
If almost nobody picks locks, a pick-resistant cylinder solves the rarest version of the problem. Offenders force the frame, and the lock survives. A standard exterior door is usually held by a strike plate fixed with short screws into soft trim, so a single kick transfers the load straight into that wood. Long screws driven through the frame into the structural stud behind it cost a few dollars and change the failure mode entirely.
What the alarm actually does
Alarms came fourth, and the detail underneath the ranking is more useful than the position.
The alarm is checked before, and it works before
Reported behaviour around alarm systems.
Source: Blevins & Kuhns, UNC Charlotte burglar survey.
Occupancy is something you can manufacture
The strongest deterrent in the study is somebody being home. If you cannot be home, the practical question is how convincingly a house can look occupied. It is the cheapest part of the whole subject and the part most people do badly, since the signals that give an empty house away are mostly signals of routine interrupted.
What broadcasts that a house is empty
Each of these is a visible change from the normal pattern of the street.
Source: deterrent ranking from Blevins & Kuhns, UNC Charlotte burglar survey; occupancy cues as applied practice.
What actually helps, in order
Ranked against what the burglars said
The first four are free.
Source: deterrent and entry-method findings, Blevins & Kuhns, UNC Charlotte burglar survey.
The hardware worth buying (paid link)
Chosen to match the ranking above rather than the marketing.
Browse on Amazon →
Browse on Amazon →
Browse on Amazon →
Browse on Amazon →
Three things we are deliberately not linking. Dummy cameras and fake alarm boxes. They are aimed at people who look, and the survey says 83% of burglars look. A dummy is identifiable at close range by exactly the person you are trying to fool, and it produces no footage when it fails. “Beware of dog” signs without a dog. A real dog ranked third; a sign is not evidence of one, and the same survey found signage in general — including neighbourhood watch signs — ranked low. High-security lock cylinders as a first purchase. They are good products solving a problem that accounted for about 12% of entries. If your door frame is held by half-inch screws, spend the money there first. Also worth saying: a camera is a privacy decision as well as a security one, since it records your neighbours and visitors and sends that footage somewhere — a point we made at more length in our piece on what your devices give away.
What the official pages say to do about burglary
This section collects what US and UK police, justice agencies and statistics offices say about preventing burglary. It is general information, not security or legal advice.
| Topic | What the pages say |
|---|---|
| Look occupied | Secured by Design (holiday advice; a police-linked scheme run by a company, Police Crime Prevention Initiatives Limited) suggests timer plugs or light-sensitive bulbs, stopping deliveries, asking a trusted neighbour to collect post and open and close curtains, and not posting holiday plans on social media. The City of Hayward, California (police page) suggests lights, radio and TV on timers and stopping mail. |
| Doors and windows | Secured by Design (home security) says to lock doors and windows even when you leave briefly, make the garage-to-house door as secure as the front door, and double-lock UPVC doors by lifting the handle and turning the key. A US Justice Department problem-oriented policing guide (COPS Office, 2004) says moderate lock security should suffice, found no evidence that elaborate locks reduce burglary, and says houses with two or more security devices were less likely to be entered. |
| Keys and valuables | Secured by Design: keep keys, including car keys, out of sight and away from the letterbox, keep laptops and tablets out of view from windows, and mark valuables. |
| Alarms, cameras and lights | The police.uk page says CCTV does not prevent crime and is no substitute for good physical security, recommends accredited alarms with audible boxes mounted high, and a low white light from dusk to dawn. The COPS guide cites a 1991 study with burglary risk of 1.4% with alarms against 2.3% without, and cautions against assuming this holds elsewhere. |
| How burglars get in | The FBI’s 2024 summary counts 397,867 forcible entries, 275,270 unlawful entries without force and 48,696 attempted forcible entries (trend data from 15,060 agencies). That works out to about 55%, 38% and 7% (our arithmetic). The UK ONS, in a 2017 article, found entry through a door about 70% of the time and a window about 30%, with someone at home in over half of cases. |
| How common it is | The Bureau of Justice Statistics (Criminal Victimization, 2023) reports 9.0 burglaries per 1,000 households in 2023. |
| If you come home to signs of a break-in | Police Scotland (advice page) says not to go inside in case the intruder is still there, to go to a neighbour or another safe place, and to call 999 if the intruder may still be inside or 101 if they have gone. Hayward gives the same advice not to go in. The Police National Legal Database (askthe.police.uk) adds: do not clean up, avoid the door the offender used, and write down any description or vehicle registration. |
We could not confirm an FBI or National Police Chiefs’ Council household-security page, a BJS figure for the share of burglaries involving forced entry (the BJS pages we read give none), or a Metropolitan Police burglary-facts page, which would not load. The COPS guide’s statement that offenders force entry in about two-thirds of burglaries gives no source, so we used the FBI counts instead.
What to do
Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested
Before
- Lock what is already there: back doors, ground-floor windows, the side gate, the garage door. The most common entry is through something left open. Measured see Sources
- Make the house look occupied: varied lighting, parcels collected, bins moved. Occupancy ranked first among deterrents in the burglar survey. Measured see Sources
- Get to know one neighbour who will notice a van and take in a parcel. Untested see Sources
- Fix the door frame: long screws through the strike plate and hinges into the stud behind. Untested see Sources
- If you have an alarm or camera, make it visible from the street. It works before entry, not during. Measured see Sources
Afterwards
- Photograph valuable items and note serial numbers now. It does nothing to prevent a burglary and a great deal for the insurance claim. Untested see Sources
What not to do
- Do not rely on dummy cameras or fake alarm boxes. The burglars who look, and most do, can tell. Measured see Sources
Questions people ask
Do burglars really work at night?
Less than the films suggest. The survey found no strong overall preference between day and night, with some variation by offender. That undercuts the whole model of night-time security: the empty house in the middle of a weekday is a perfectly good target, and most households leave it unattended most reliably.
Am I being watched and chosen?
Usually not. Just over a third gathered advance information, and 62% described the burglary as spur of the moment. The realistic picture is opportunity: someone is passing, something about the house says nobody is in and nothing will react, and the decision takes seconds. That is reassuring, and it is also why the cheap signals work.
Is a monitored alarm worth the monthly fee?
That depends on what you are buying it for. As a deterrent, most of the effect comes from the system being visibly alarmed, and a self-monitored one delivers that as well. As a response, monitoring buys someone else noticing when you are away and cannot. The marketing blends the two, so decide which you want before comparing prices.
What about a dog?
A dog ranked third, above alarms and cameras, through noise and unpredictability rather than size. It is also a fifteen-year commitment to a living animal, and a terrible reason to acquire one. If you already have a dog, it is doing more security work than your lock. If you do not, this is no argument for getting one.
Should I confront someone if it happens?
No. Everything in this article aims to make the house a worse option before anyone is inside, so that this question stays hypothetical. If someone is in the house, the property is insured and you are not. Get out or stay put somewhere secure, and call the police.
The short version
- 422 incarcerated burglars were asked directly. 62% called it spur of the moment.
- The top deterrents were occupancy, police proximity and a dog, ahead of alarms and cameras.
- Fewer than a third rated lighting, watch signs or a full mailbox as a factor.
- Only about 12% picked a lock or used a key. Nearly everyone else went through something open or forced.
- So the weak point is the door frame, not the cylinder. Long screws into the stud.
- 83% checked for an alarm before attempting, and 60% would go elsewhere if they found one.
- Once inside, only about half would stop. The alarm works before, so make it visible.
- Occupancy can be manufactured: varied lights, collected parcels, moved bins, no live holiday posts.
- Skip the dummy camera and the dog sign. The people they are aimed at are the people who look closely.
- The study was funded by the alarm industry. Its own product came fourth, which is the main reason to trust it.
This article summarises one offender survey and general crime prevention practice. Burglary patterns vary a great deal by country and neighbourhood, and your local police force usually publishes area-specific advice that reflects what is actually happening near you. Nothing here is advice about confronting an intruder, and the law on defending property differs sharply between jurisdictions.
On the links above: some are affiliate links, marked (paid link). If you buy through one we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We link to product searches rather than specific items so that recommendations do not break as models change, and we say plainly when we are choosing not to link something. Full policy: Affiliate Disclosure.
Sources
- Blevins, K.R. & Kuhns, J.B. Understanding Decisions to Burglarize from the Offender’s Perspective. University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Department of Criminal Justice and Criminology; sponsored by the Alarm Industry Research and Educational Foundation. (422 incarcerated burglars across three states; 62% spur of the moment; deterrent ranking; 83% checked for an alarm; 60% would seek another target; about half would stop mid-attempt and 13% would always continue; about 12% picked locks or used keys; about 20% cut alarm or telephone wires; fewer than one third rated lighting, neighbourhood watch signs or a full mailbox.)
- University of North Carolina at Charlotte. “Through the eyes of a burglar: study provides insights on habits and motivations, importance of security,” 2013.
- Secured by Design. Home Security securedbydesign.com; Ensure your home is secure whilst on holiday securedbydesign.com.
- police.uk. Keep burglars out of your property police.uk. Police Scotland. Break-in and housebreaking scotland.police.uk. Police National Legal Database. Burglary askthe.police.uk.
- City of Hayward, CA. Home Security Tips hayward-ca.gov.
- FBI UCR. Summary of Reported Crimes in the Nation, 2024, Aug. 2025 cde.ucr.cjis.gov. BJS. Criminal Victimization, 2023 bjs.ojp.gov. COPS Office. Burglary of Single-Family Houses, Problem-Specific Guide No. 18, Aug. 2004 cops.usdoj.gov. ONS. Overview of burglary and other household theft, July 20, 2017 ons.gov.uk.
