Ice hockey injuries, body checking and the rule that halved them
Key takeaways · 9 min read
- In men’s college hockey the rate is about 9.5 injuries per 1,000 exposures, similar to football, and in women’s about 6.1.
- Games produce most injuries, and body checking is behind many of them.
- In Canada, taking checking out of ages 11–12 cut game injuries by 50% and concussions by 64%.
- Full face masks prevent most facial and eye injuries but not concussion.
In 2013 Hockey Canada took body checking out of Pee Wee hockey, for players aged 11 and 12, across the country. Researchers in Calgary compared the seasons before and after: game injuries fell from 4.37 to 2.16 per 1,000 game-hours, and concussions from 2.79 to 1.12. After adjustment, that was a 50% drop in injuries and a 64% drop in concussions.
Few sports have a result that clean. Ice hockey is a fast collision sport played on a hard surface with sticks and blades, and it is injured accordingly: at college level men’s hockey sits alongside American football. Its injuries are unusually tied to specific, changeable things, though: whether a league allows checking, what players wear on their faces, and, since the death of a professional player in England in 2023, what they wear on their necks.
This article covers what hockey players actually injure, where the risk concentrates, what has been measured to reduce it, and why the answer is not to hang up the skates.
What actually gets injured
From 2009 to 2014, the CDC’s summary of US college sport put men’s ice hockey at 9.5 injuries per 1,000 athlete-exposures and women’s at 6.1, against an average of 6.0 across 25 sports. Wrestling, at 13.1, and women’s gymnastics, at 10.4, were higher. Men’s hockey and baseball were the only two sports in which more injuries happened in games than in practice.
Hockey among college sports
Injuries per 1,000 athlete-exposures, NCAA, 2009–10 to 2013–14.
Source: Kerr et al., MMWR 64(48):1330–1336 (2015).
What gets hurt depends on who is playing. Among 15- to 17-year-olds in Canadian leagues that allow checking, the head and face took 32.9% of game injuries, the shoulder and collarbone 17.8%, the wrist and hand 9.9% and the knee 9.4%, and concussion was the single commonest injury. In a Swiss professional league over seven seasons, the rate was 5.93 injuries per 1,000 player-hours, and the lower limb accounted for 40.4%, led by tears of the ligament on the inside of the knee and strains of the groin and abdomen.
Adult recreational players meet a different side of the game, and often the face. An analysis of US emergency departments estimated 68,786 adult hockey injuries from 2007 to 2016. Lacerations were the commonest diagnosis, at 26.4%, and the face the commonest site, at 18.1%, followed by the head and the shoulder; concussion was 7.0% of visits. Adult recreational leagues usually ban checking, so what remains is sticks, pucks, falls and the occasional collision.
When the risk concentrates
Games, and checking. From the college counts, the injury rate in men’s games works out at roughly 26 per 1,000 exposures against about 4 in practice, a gap the CDC report described as more than five-fold. In US high school boys, games carried 7.8 times the injury rate of practice, and body checking was the mechanism in more than 46% of injuries. Among Canadian youth, game concussion rates rose with age, from 1.82 per 1,000 game-hours under 13 to 3.47 under 15 and 3.61 under 18, and girls had about 1.7 times the concussion rate of boys.

The rarest injury changed the rules. On 28 October 2023, Adam Johnson, a 29-year-old American playing for the Nottingham Panthers, died after an opponent’s skate blade cut his neck during a game in Sheffield. In April 2025 prosecutors in England decided not to bring charges; the inquest has not yet concluded. Injuries like this are extremely uncommon. A US registry of catastrophic sports injuries counted 26 serious hockey lacerations from 1982 to 2025, 24 of them from skates and 15 to the neck. In a survey of more than 26,000 USA Hockey members, 1.8% said they had ever had a neck laceration, and the cases followed up were superficial. Registry and survey counts like these cannot give a rate per game, but they show how far this risk sits below concussion, which youth leagues record every week.
Concussion by age in Canadian youth hockey
Game concussions per 1,000 game-hours, Safe2Play cohort, 2013–2018.
Source: Eliason et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine, conference abstract (2024).
The pattern is old. Across 16 seasons of older NCAA data, from 1988 to 2004, men’s games produced 16.27 injuries per 1,000 exposures against 1.96 in practice, a rate ratio of 8.3. The commonest game injury to the lower limb was internal damage to the knee. The shape of the risk has changed little over the decades; the rules and equipment built around it have changed, which is why the next section is longer than usual.
What has been measured to work
Canada ran a series of natural experiments, which gives body-checking policy the strongest evidence of any prevention measure in youth sport. In 2007–08, Carolyn Emery’s group compared Pee Wee players in Alberta, where checking was allowed, with those in Quebec, where it was not. Alberta players had 3.26 times the game injury rate and 3.88 times the concussion rate. A second comparison found almost the same gap when Ontario dropped checking a few years later. Then Hockey Canada removed checking from Pee Wee nationally, and the before-and-after study in Calgary found the 50% and 64% falls in injuries and concussions quoted at the top.
Checking removed, older age groups
Adjusted rate ratios below 1.00 mean fewer injuries in leagues without checking. Corrected figures, 2024.
Injuries: 0.45 (0.27–0.76)
Concussions: 0.59 (0.30–1.17)
Severe injuries: 0.39
Concussion result not significant
Injuries: 0.33 (0.21–0.51)
Concussions: 0.41 (0.23–0.73)
About 8,770 injuries a year prevented
Estimate for Canada, 5,111–12,429
Source: Emery et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine 54(7):414–420 (2020) and 56(1):12 (2022), both corrected in 2024.

The same group then looked at older players, in leagues that allow checking and leagues that do not. Among 13- and 14-year-olds, non-checking leagues had 55% fewer injuries, though the fall in concussions did not reach significance. Among 15- to 17-year-olds, they had 67% fewer injuries and 59% fewer concussions, and the authors estimated about 8,770 injuries a year could be prevented in Canada. These papers were corrected in 2024, and the figures here are the corrected ones. A common objection, that children who never learn to check will be hurt more when they meet it later, was tested too. Players who had learned to check earlier were not protected later on, so delaying checking does not simply move the injuries to an older age.
Face protection in junior hockey
Injuries per 1,000 player-game hours by type of face protection, and a review comparing shields with full masks.
Source: Stuart et al., American Journal of Sports Medicine 30(1):39–44 (2002); Asplund et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine (2009).
A second clear lesson concerns face protection. In a study of junior players, injuries ran at 158.9 per 1,000 player-game hours without face protection, 73.5 with a half shield and 23.2 with a full face mask, and the full-protection group had no eye or neck injuries. A systematic review found half shields carried 2.31 times the facial injuries of full masks. Neither made a difference to concussion, which comes from the brain moving inside the skull rather than a blow to the face. Mouthguards were linked to lower concussion odds in one observational study of youth players, an adjusted odds ratio of 0.36, but that design cannot prove cause. Neck guards have been mandatory in English hockey since January 2024, in US youth hockey since August 2024, and in the NHL for players who debut from the 2026–27 season. In laboratory tests, most guards resisted a skate blade at lower force but failed at higher force, and no study has yet shown they prevent deaths; they are a reasonable precaution adopted ahead of the evidence.
Why the answer is not to stop
Hockey’s injury rates are high but in line with other collision sports, and they respond unusually well to change. Men’s college hockey at 9.5 injuries per 1,000 exposures sits beside football at 9.2 and below wrestling at 13.1; women’s hockey, played without checking, is at the all-sport average. More to the point, the biggest single driver of youth injuries turned out to be a rule, and the rule could be changed without changing whether children play. About half a million Canadians under 18 play hockey each year.
What the national Pee Wee change did
Calgary, seasons before and after body checking was removed for ages 11–12 in 2013.
Source: Black et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine 51(24):1767–1772 (2017).

For players and parents, the evidence supports practical choices over a yes-or-no decision. Choose non-checking leagues for younger and recreational players, where injury rates fall by half or more. Wear a full face mask, which removes most facial and eye injuries. Wear a mouthguard and a neck guard: the evidence for both is weaker, but the cost is low. Take concussion seriously at every age, because the rates climb through the teenage years and are higher in girls. The rarest disasters, like Adam Johnson’s death, prompted sensible changes that are still waiting for outcome data.
This series keeps finding that a sport’s risk is not fixed. Hockey in Quebec and hockey in Alberta were the same game on the same ice, with three times the injury rate on one side of a provincial border. That difference came from a rule.
What the official pages say about ice hockey body checking
Hockey bodies, health societies and government pages describe the checking age in different ways, and the best outcome data comes from one Canadian rule change. This section sets out what the pages say. It is general information, not medical advice.
| Source | What it says |
|---|---|
| USA Hockey (non-government), Changing the dangerous play culture (Mar. 15, 2018) | Body checking is not allowed in youth games until the 14U level, and contact is taught at 12U. A 2021 article (Sept. 14, 2021) says the 2021–25 rules target hits on defenseless players and rename the rulebook term “competitive contact”, with no age rule. The age classifications page does not mention checking. |
| Hockey Canada (non-government), Checking (page timestamp Oct. 27, 2026) | Body checking is the fourth step of a four-step progression and begins at U15, and is not permitted before U15 at most intermediate and competitive levels; some community leagues offer non-checking options at all ages. The page does not mention the 2013 change. |
| CBC News (news report), Hockey Canada bans body checking at Peewee (2013 annual meeting) | The board voted overwhelmingly to ban body checking at Peewee (ages 11–12), effective 2013–14; only Saskatchewan voted against. Cites Alberta research showing about three times the injury risk for Peewees who check versus Quebec, which waits until Bantam. |
| Canadian Paediatric Society (non-government), Media release (Nov. 2, 2012, before the ban) | Stale. Advised delaying checking in competitive leagues until Bantam (13–14) and banning it in non-competitive leagues at all ages. The related statement in Paediatrics & Child Health 2012;17(9):509 grades the evidence II-2A for removing checking from recreational male hockey and III-C for delaying it in elite male leagues. No injury figures. |
| Alberta Peewee before/after study (journal, non-government), British Journal of Sports Medicine 2017;51(24):1767, via a CBC summary | Game injuries fell from 4.37 to 2.16 per 1,000 game-hours (rate ratio 0.50, 95% CI 0.33–0.75) and concussions from 2.79 to 1.12 (rate ratio 0.36, 95% CI 0.22–0.58). The CBC story reports 64% fewer concussions and 50% fewer injuries; its estimate of about 4,800 fewer concussions a year in Canada is a researcher’s estimate, not an official figure. |
| CDC (US government), HEADS UP data (Jan. 27, 2026) | Boys’ ice hockey ranks 4th in youth concussion rates. In high-school hockey, concussions are 13 times more likely in games than in practices; nearly two-thirds come from player-to-player collisions, and about one-third follow a body check. |
| Public Health Agency of Canada (Canadian government), Traumatic brain injuries across the life course (modified Nov. 19, 2020) | Hockey had the highest share of sport brain injuries among ages 5–19. Among male organized-hockey brain injuries at ages 10–19, the share peaked at ages 13–14 and declined after 2013. Our extraction described the 2013 ban as being for Bantam players, which conflicts with CBC and the journal study (Peewee), so check the original wording. |
| Health Canada (Canadian government), Helmet safety (modified Dec. 8, 2025) | Hockey helmets are multi-impact but must be replaced if visibly damaged. Look for the CSA mark on helmets, face protectors and visors, check that face protectors fit the helmet, and do not modify gear. No figures. A US CPSC brochure (about May 2022) lists ice hockey helmets under voluntary standards NOCSAE ND030 and ASTM F1045. |
| NHS (UK government), Head injury and concussion (reviewed May 29, 2025) | Concussion is temporary, symptoms can last up to 2 weeks, and contact sports should be avoided for at least 3 weeks. Call 999 for loss of consciousness, seizure, vision or hearing problems, or fluid from the ears or nose. MedlinePlus (Nov. 24, 2025) also covers concussion warning signs and does not mention helmets. |
| Our comparison | The age at which checking starts is different in each body: USA Hockey 14U, Hockey Canada U15 in most competitive play, and the Canadian Paediatric Society Bantam or older. All of these are non-government bodies, and we have not tried to say which is right. |
We could not confirm what the American Academy of Pediatrics 2014 body-checking statement says, because its page did not load; the AAP is non-government and one headline we saw about “raise the age to 15” was not verified. We also could not confirm a Hockey Canada page describing the 2013 Peewee change (only CBC and the journal abstract support it), an official USA Hockey rulebook entry for the age, the 2011 USA Hockey vote beyond one unofficial blog, or any face-mask effectiveness figure from CPSC or Health Canada. The last part of the Canadian government page was not read. Figures were read through automated page fetches, so confirm exact numbers on the live pages.
What to do
Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested
Before
- Choose non-checking leagues for younger and recreational players. Removing checking for ages 11–12 cut game injuries by 50% and concussions by 64%. Measured see Sources
- Wear a full face mask. Injuries ran at 23.2 per 1,000 player-game hours with one, against 158.9 without face protection. Measured see Sources
- Wear a mouthguard and a neck guard. The evidence is weaker, but the cost is low. Untested see Sources
Afterwards
- Have any suspected concussion assessed by a doctor and follow a graded return-to-sport protocol. Official advice see Sources
What not to do
- Do not expect a face mask to prevent concussion. Rates were similar with half shields and full masks. Measured see Sources
Questions people ask
How common are ice hockey injuries?
College men are injured at about 9.5 per 1,000 exposures and women at 6.1, against an all-sport average of 6.0. Most injuries happen in games.
At what age is body checking allowed in youth hockey?
In Canada and the United States it was removed from the 11–12 age group, in 2013 and 2011 respectively. Removing it halved injuries and cut concussions by 64% in one study.
Do full face masks prevent concussion?
No. They greatly reduce facial, eye and dental injuries, but concussion rates were similar with half shields and full masks.
Are neck guards mandatory in hockey?
In English hockey since 2024, in US youth hockey since August 2024, and in the NHL for players debuting from 2026–27. No study has yet measured their effect on serious injuries.
Is women’s hockey safer than men’s?
Women’s college hockey, played without body checking, has a lower overall injury rate. But among youth, girls had higher concussion rates than boys.
The short version
- In men’s college hockey the rate is about 9.5 injuries per 1,000 exposures, similar to football, and in women’s about 6.1.
- Games produce most injuries, and body checking is behind many of them.
- In Canada, taking checking out of ages 11–12 cut game injuries by 50% and concussions by 64%.
- Full face masks prevent most facial and eye injuries but not concussion.
- Neck guards became mandatory after Adam Johnson’s 2023 death, ahead of outcome evidence.
This is a summary of published research, not medical advice. Any suspected concussion should be assessed by a doctor before returning to play, following a graded return-to-sport protocol.
Further reading: Emery et al., JAMA 303(22):2265–2272 (2010), for the Alberta–Quebec comparison. Black et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine 51(24):1767–1772 (2017), for the national policy change. Our article on American football and the kickoff rule tells a similar story.
Sources
- Black AM, Macpherson AK, Hagel BE, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine 51(24):1767–1772 (2017), doi:10.1136/bjsports-2016-097392.
- Kerr ZY, Marshall SW, Dompier TP, Corlette J, Klossner DA, Gilchrist J. MMWR 64(48):1330–1336 (2015).
- Emery CA, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine 56(1):12 (2022), doi:10.1136/bjsports-2020-103757, corrected 2024.
- Ornon G, et al. Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics (2020), doi:10.1186/s40634-020-00300-3.
- Morrissey PJ, et al. Journal of Orthopaedics (2020), doi:10.1016/j.jor.2020.04.015.
- Matic GT, et al. The Physician and Sportsmedicine (2015), doi:10.1080/00913847.2015.1035210.
- Eliason P, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine, conference abstract (2024), doi:10.1136/bjsports-2023-concussion.368.
- Kucera KL, et al. (2026), doi:10.17615/x2bb-b223.
- Yorkshire Post, 27 April 2026; NBC News, April 2025.
- Emery CA, Kang J, Shrier I, et al. JAMA 303(22):2265–2272 (2010), doi:10.1001/jama.2010.755.
- Black AM, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine 50:55–61 (2016), doi:10.1136/bjsports-2015-095103.
- Emery C, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine 54(7):414–420 (2020), doi:10.1136/bjsports-2019-101092, corrected 2024.
- Eliason P, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine 56(23):1337 (2022).
- Stuart MJ, et al. American Journal of Sports Medicine 30(1):39–44 (2002).
- Asplund C, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine (2009), doi:10.1136/bjsm.2009.060152.
- Chisholm DA, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine 54(14):866 (2020), doi:10.1136/bjsports-2019-101011.
- Loyd AM, et al. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine (2015), doi:10.1097/JSM.0000000000000121.
- Morrissette CR, et al. American Journal of Sports Medicine (2026), doi:10.1177/03635465251380851.
- USA Hockey, neck laceration protection rule, effective 1 August 2024.
- NHL.com, new collective bargaining agreement, 21 July 2025.
- Fox News, 30 October 2023, on the EIHA neck guard mandate.
- USA Hockey, dangerous play culture (non-government); Hockey Canada, checking (non-government); Canadian Paediatric Society release (non-government); CDC, HEADS UP data; Health Canada, helmet safety; NHS, head injury and concussion.
