Dark cover tile reading 64% and no crash, over a subtitle about killed or seriously injured bus and coach passengers in Great Britain.
|

Sixty-Four Per Cent of Seriously Injured British Bus Passengers Were Never in a Crash. And the Bus Is Still About Four Times Safer Than the Car.

Key takeaways · 12 min read

  • In Great Britain, 64.3% of bus and coach passengers killed or seriously injured were hurt in incidents involving no collision.
  • Women made up 74.2% of those non-collision casualties, and 58.0% were aged 60 or over.
  • Passengers who were not seated had roughly double the odds of a serious outcome: 8.3% against 4.1%.
  • Pooled risk for falls inside a moving vehicle is about 0.3–0.5 injuries per million passenger kilometres, and for boarding and alighting 0.8–1.7 per million passengers.

Per kilometre travelled, riding a city bus down a major road is roughly four times safer than driving a car down the same road, and that holds for the people walking and cycling alongside it too. The figure comes from a study that measured ten Montreal bus corridors over ten years, about as clean a comparison as this literature offers.

Now the other number. In Great Britain, 64.3 per cent of bus and coach passengers killed or seriously injured were hurt in incidents involving no collision at all. Nothing hit the bus and the bus hit nothing. Somebody was standing when it braked, or stepped down onto a kerb that was not where they expected it.

Both things are true, and together they make up the whole subject: the mode is safe and the moment is not. What follows covers what the injury data actually contain, why the two dangerous moments have different physics, and why the risk falls almost entirely on one group of passengers.

A pointillist illustration of a lit bus standing at a stop at dusk, its windows glowing over a wet road.
The mode is safe. The moment the doors open is not.

What the casualty data actually contain

The police collect British road casualty records on a form called STATS19. It is built around road traffic accidents, so bus passengers appear almost as an afterthought. When Loughborough researchers went through it looking specifically at bus and coach passengers, they found that non-collision cases were the majority.

Among killed or seriously injured passengers, 64.3 per cent were injured without a collision. Women accounted for 74.2 per cent of those casualties, nearly three quarters, and 58.0 per cent were aged 60 or over. Almost half of all seriously injured passengers, 49.0 per cent, were both unseated and in a vehicle that had not been struck.

The same analysis put a number on what sitting down is worth. A passenger who was not seated had an 8.3 per cent chance of being killed or seriously injured, against 4.1 per cent for a seated one, roughly double.

Killed or seriously injured bus and coach passengers, Great Britain

Injured with no collision at all64.3%
Of those non-collision casualties, women74.2%
Aged 60 or over58.0%
Both not seated and no impact49.0%

Not seated: 8.3% chance of a killed-or-seriously-injured outcome. Seated: 4.1%. Bus design changed over this period — low-floor access made buses usable by less mobile passengers, which the authors note may raise exposure at the same time as it improves access.

Kirk, A., Grant, R. and Bird, R., “Passenger casualties in non-collision incidents on buses and coaches in Great Britain”, Loughborough University, 2003, using STATS19 national road accident data.

Two moments, two different mechanisms

Non-collision injury splits cleanly into falling inside a moving vehicle and falling while getting on or off one. The two are measured against different denominators, because one depends on distance and the other on the number of trips.

A pointillist illustration of the bottom step of a bus and the gap to the kerb, lit by the door light.
Boarding risk is counted per passenger, not per kilometre travelled.

Rune Elvik reconstructed exposure for eleven studies and produced comparable estimates for both. The mean risk of falling inside a moving vehicle is about 0.3 to 0.5 injuries per million passenger kilometres. For boarding or alighting it is about 0.8 to 1.7 per million passengers, counted per person getting on or off whatever distance follows. On a short urban trip, most of the risk sits in the boarding and alighting.

An older American dataset shows the same shape from the inside. Washington’s transit authority recorded more than 5,000 bus passenger injuries. A third occurred during boarding and alighting and another quarter while the bus was stopping. Of the injuries on stopping buses, 45 per cent happened to passengers who were getting up, sitting down, or already seated. A third of the alighting injuries were trips and slips.

Where the injuries happen, and against which denominator

Falling inside a moving vehicleBoarding or alighting
Pooled risk estimate0.3–0.5 injuries per million passenger kilometres0.8–1.7 injuries per million passengers
TriggerBraking, acceleration, cornering. Standing, or moving to or from a seat.The step, the gap, the kerb, the doors closing.
Share of hospitalised cases (Israel, 2015–17)75%25%
Share of recorded injuries (Washington DC)~25% during stopping, of which 45% while getting up, sitting down or seated~33%, a third of them trips and slips

Elvik, R., “Risk of non-collision injuries to public transport passengers”, Journal of Transport & Health, 2019; Siman-Tov, M. et al., Israeli National Trauma Registry, 2019; Fruin, J.J. et al., Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority data, 1994.

The physics of standing up

Buses routinely cross a measured threshold here. A Dublin group instrumented urban buses, recorded real acceleration profiles, and ran a validated human model of a standing passenger holding a handgrip. Peak accelerations reached ±0.32g, while the reported threshold at which a standing passenger holding on loses balance is about 0.15g.

That is roughly double the level at which a person holding a rail can be expected to stay upright, and it occurs in normal driving. Their model could not predict when balance would actually be lost, but it could estimate what happens afterwards: a maximum predicted probability of knee injury of 53 per cent and of head injury of 35 per cent from contact with seats, handrails and walls. The stairwell and the horizontal handles on the backs of seats came out as particularly hazardous, and the authors recommended replacing the latter with vertical handrails.

What a bus does, against what a standing passenger can absorb

Peak acceleration measured on urban buses in normal service0.32g
Reported threshold for losing balance while holding a handgrip0.15g

Predicted probability of injury once a fall begins: knee 53%, head 35%, from contact with seats, handrails and walls. From a validated human model, not from observed falls.

Palacio, A., Tamburro, G., O’Neill, D. and Simms, C., Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2008.

A Swedish study of three and a half years of emergency department cases refines the mechanism. Falls under acceleration and falls under braking are different events. Under acceleration, older passengers most often fall immediately after boarding, before they have reached anything to hold. Women are heavily involved in younger age groups as well as the over-65 group, which the authors read as a hint that the acceleration thresholds for keeping balance may differ by sex.

Who this actually happens to

Israel’s national trauma registry covers twenty hospitals. Between 2015 and 2017 it recorded 704 people hospitalised after a non-collision bus injury: seventy-five per cent fell inside the bus and 25 per cent while boarding or alighting, sixty-seven per cent were aged 60 or over, and seventy-two per cent were women. The commonly injured regions were the lower limbs, the head and the torso.

An earlier prospective study across six Israeli emergency departments found the same profile in less severe cases: 120 patients, 86 of them women, more than half over 55, most of them standing when hurt. There were no fatalities and 17 were admitted.

A systematic review of ten studies from high-income countries reached the same conclusion: more than 6,000 people a year are injured on public buses in the United Kingdom, about half aged 65 or over. Most injuries happen in daytime hours on weekdays, on ordinary journeys away from the edges of the timetable.

704 people hospitalised after a bus injury with no crash

Israeli National Trauma Registry, twenty hospitals, 2015–2017.

75%Fell inside the bus rather than while boarding or alighting. The remaining 25% were hurt at the door or the kerb.
67%Aged 60 or over. In the British data the equivalent figure for serious casualties is 58% aged 60 or over.
72%Women. Every dataset in this literature finds the same imbalance, and no study has isolated why.

Siman-Tov, M., Radomislensky, I., Marom, I., Kapra, O., Peleg, K. and Bahouth, H., Journal of Transport & Health, 2019.

And the bus is still much safer than the car

A Montreal study picked ten bus routes along major arterials, estimated car and bus passenger kilometres from vehicle and automatic on-board passenger counts, and pulled ten years of police injury reports for every mode. Per passenger kilometre, car occupants were injured at 3.7 times the bus occupant rate (confidence interval 3.4 to 4.0), and at 6.3 times for fatal or severe injuries. Pedestrian injury associated with car travel ran at 4.1 times that associated with bus travel, and cyclist injury at 5.3 times.

Combining all three groups, travelling by car on those roads was associated with 3.8 times the injury rate of travelling by bus. The authors then asked what would happen if every bus passenger kilometre were shifted to cars. Across the ten routes over ten years, bus travel had avoided an estimated 2,437 injuries, 105 of them severe or fatal.

Car travel versus bus travel, per passenger kilometre

Injury rate ratios on ten Montreal arterial bus corridors, 2001–2010. Above 1 means car travel is worse.

Vehicle occupants, severe or fatal injuries6.3
Cyclist injuries associated with the mode5.3
Pedestrian injuries associated with the mode4.1
Vehicle occupants, all severities (95% CI 3.4–4.0)3.7

The authors note they are more likely to have over-estimated car passenger kilometres than under-estimated them, which would make these ratios conservative. Exposure came from counts taken on a single day and was not varied over the ten-year period — their main stated limitation.

Morency, P., Strauss, J., Pépin, F., Tessier, F. and Grondines, J., “Traveling by Bus Instead of Car on Urban Major Roads”, Journal of Urban Health, 2018.

Riding the bus: what officials say about holding on and sitting down

Official advice for bus passengers is thin. This section sets out what we could confirm and where it stops.

What the pages say
SourceWhat it says
Transport for London (2025)“Hold the handrail especially on stairs and escalators, and onboard moving vehicles.” Nothing on seating, standing or the bell.
London Assembly Transport Committee (Mar. 2024; a political body, not TfL)Reports TfL’s view that the recent rise in serious injuries is largely passengers slipping, tripping or falling, often when alighting or when brakes are applied. TfL’s analysis found harsh braking or sudden movement to be the main cause, including passengers not seated when the bus moves. Older people were more likely to be injured. TfL suggested fewer passengers hold on since Covid-19, and was trialling a departure bell.
US FMCSA, motorcoach passengers (page updated July 2019)Recommends shoulder/lap belts where fitted; says operators should point out the emergency exits; advises passengers to stay seated as much as possible while moving, use handrails when boarding, exiting or walking, and follow the driver’s directions.
DfT, Reported road casualties Great Britain 2025 (July 30, 2026)Bus or coach occupants: 5 killed, 323 killed or seriously injured, 2,036 casualties of all severities. Covers road collisions only, and the page notes some under-recording.

The practical reading, which is ours: the evidence the officials cite points at the moments of braking and alighting, so sitting when you can and keeping one hand on a rail when you cannot is the advice that fits the data.

What we could not confirm: official UK wording on when to stand up or press the bell, any US transit-bus guidance from the FTA, and a numeric share of bus injuries that happen without a collision in any official release we could open. A US DOT page describes a rule requiring lap-shoulder belts on new motorcoaches and other large buses (not transit or school buses), but its date conflicted with its own text, so we do not print one.

How well we actually know any of this

Badly, and the researchers say so. Elvik could reconstruct exposure for only eleven studies, and rated half of those exposure estimates as very or somewhat uncertain. Risk estimates vary substantially from study to study, and his summary of why is unusually blunt: largely for unknown reasons.

The fog has a structural cause. Non-collision injuries mostly do not reach police road accident data, because no accident in the legal sense has occurred. They surface in emergency departments, in an operator’s liability file, or nowhere. A Swedish group argues that assessing bus travel properly requires a travel chain view (the walk to the stop, the wait, the boarding, the ride, the alighting), and that police data covers almost none of it.

The risk factors themselves therefore differ between the two kinds of incident. A Hong Kong analysis of 17,383 injured franchised bus passengers over ten years found that the factors raising injury severity in non-collision incidents were substantially inconsistent with those in collisions. What governs how badly you are hurt when a bus is struck differs from what governs it when the bus merely brakes.

Three sentences that are all supported

TRUEMost seriously injured bus passengers were never in a crash. The injury happened while the vehicle was behaving normally.
TRUERiding the bus is several times safer per kilometre than driving the same road, and safer for the people outside the vehicle too.
ALSO TRUEWe do not know the size of the problem well. Half the exposure estimates in the largest synthesis were rated uncertain, and non-collision injuries mostly never reach road accident data at all.
A pointillist illustration of the aisle of a bus, stanchion poles receding towards a bright windscreen.
A standing passenger loses balance at about 0.15g. Normal urban driving reaches twice that.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

If it happens

  • Get to something to hold, or sit down, as soon as you board. Older passengers most often fell immediately after boarding, before reaching a handhold. Measured see Sources
  • Prefer a seat to standing if you can. Normal bus driving reached 0.32g, about double the 0.15g at which a standing passenger holding on loses balance. Measured see Sources
  • Hold a vertical rail rather than a horizontal seat-back handle, and take extra care on the stairs. Measured see Sources

The bus is still about four times safer than the car.

Questions people ask

Is it really safer to take the bus?

On the evidence, yes, and by a wide margin per kilometre travelled, for you and for the people around the vehicle. Non-collision injuries are real and under-counted, but overwhelmingly non-fatal. The Israeli emergency department study had no deaths among 120 casualties, and the Montreal data show a fatal injury rate of zero for bus occupants across ten years on ten routes.

What is the single most useful thing a passenger can do?

Sit down, and stay seated until the bus has stopped. The data speaks to that behaviour directly: not being seated doubles the odds of a serious outcome, and 45 per cent of the injuries recorded on stopping buses happened to people who were getting up, sitting down, or seated but unbraced. Standing up early to be ready at the door is the specific move the numbers argue against.

If I have to stand, what should I hold?

Something vertical, if there is one. The modelling study found horizontal handles on the backs of seats to be among the more hazardous features and recommended vertical handrails instead; stairwells came out badly too. The caveat is that this comes from simulation; no trial of handrail designs exists.

Why are so many of the casualties women?

Nobody knows. It shows up in Britain, Israel, Sweden, Denmark and the United States alike. Part of it is exposure — women use buses more in most of these countries, and older women more still — but the Swedish work found the over-representation in younger age groups too, which exposure alone does not obviously explain. The authors raise the possibility that balance thresholds under acceleration differ by sex; that is a hypothesis, not a finding.

Is this getting better or worse?

Both, in different places. Washington’s passenger injury rate fell by about a third between 1976 and 1990. Against that, low-floor buses and accessibility rules have brought less mobile passengers onto services they previously could not use, which is a public good that also raises exposure among exactly the group most likely to be hurt. The British researchers make this point explicitly rather than treating it as an argument against accessibility.

The short version

  • In Great Britain, 64.3% of bus and coach passengers killed or seriously injured were hurt in incidents involving no collision.
  • Women made up 74.2% of those non-collision casualties, and 58.0% were aged 60 or over.
  • Passengers who were not seated had roughly double the odds of a serious outcome: 8.3% against 4.1%.
  • Pooled risk for falls inside a moving vehicle is about 0.3–0.5 injuries per million passenger kilometres, and for boarding and alighting 0.8–1.7 per million passengers.
  • Measured urban bus accelerations reach ±0.32g. The reported balance-loss threshold for a standing passenger holding a handgrip is about 0.15g.
  • In an Israeli registry of 704 hospitalised cases, 75% fell inside the bus, 67% were 60 or over and 72% were women.
  • Per passenger kilometre, car travel on the same roads carried 3.7 times the occupant injury rate of bus travel, 6.3 times for severe and fatal injuries, and 4.1 and 5.3 times the associated pedestrian and cyclist injury rates.
  • The exposure data underlying all of this is weak: half the estimates in the largest synthesis were rated uncertain, and the author attributes the variation between studies to unknown reasons.

This article summarises published research on injuries to public transport passengers. It is not medical advice, and it describes population averages rather than any individual’s risk. Where estimates are uncertain, the uncertainty is stated rather than smoothed over.

Further reading: Elvik’s synthesis in the Journal of Transport & Health is the best single entry point, and the Montreal study by Morency and colleagues is open access. Your own transit operator may publish passenger incident counts; most do not.

Sources

  • Kirk, A., Grant, R. and Bird, R., “Passenger casualties in non-collision incidents on buses and coaches in Great Britain”, Loughborough University, 2003. (STATS19 data. 64.3% of killed or seriously injured bus and coach passengers were injured in non-collision incidents; of those, 74.2% female, 58.0% aged 60 or over. 49.0% of KSI casualties were both not seated and in a vehicle with no impact. Not seated: 8.3% likelihood of a KSI outcome against 4.1% seated. The authors note low-floor access has widened the population able to use buses and may increase the exposure of more vulnerable passengers.)
  • Elvik, R., “Risk of non-collision injuries to public transport passengers: Synthesis of evidence from eleven studies”, Journal of Transport & Health, 2019. (Twelve risk estimates for boarding and alighting and twelve for falls onboard, from eleven studies. Mean risk of falling in a moving vehicle about 0.3–0.5 per million passenger kilometres; boarding or alighting about 0.8–1.7 per million passengers. Half the exposure estimates were rated very or somewhat uncertain, and the author states estimates vary substantially between studies largely for unknown reasons.)
  • Morency, P., Strauss, J., Pépin, F., Tessier, F. and Grondines, J., “Traveling by Bus Instead of Car on Urban Major Roads: Safety Benefits for Vehicle Occupants, Pedestrians, and Cyclists”, Journal of Urban Health, 2018. (Ten Montreal arterial bus routes, 2001–2010. Car-to-bus occupant injury rate ratio 3.7, 95% CI 3.4–4.0; 6.3 for fatal or severe, 3.4–13.3. Pedestrian 4.1, 3.5–4.9; cyclist 5.3, 3.8–7.6; all modes combined 3.8, 3.6–4.1. Bus travel estimated to have avoided 2,437 injuries over ten years across the ten routes, 105 of them severe or fatal. Bus occupant fatal injury rate 0.00 per 100 million passenger kilometres.)
  • Siman-Tov, M., Radomislensky, I., Marom, I., Kapra, O., Peleg, K. and Bahouth, H., “A nation-wide study on the prevalence of non-collision injuries occurring during use of public buses”, Journal of Transport & Health, 2019. (Israeli National Trauma Registry, twenty hospitals, 2015–2017. 704 hospitalised non-collision bus casualties: 75% fell inside the bus, 25% while boarding or alighting; 67% aged 60 or over; 72% women. Lower extremities, head and torso most frequently injured.)
  • Palacio, A., Tamburro, G., O’Neill, D. and Simms, C., “Non-collision injuries in urban buses — strategies for prevention”, Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2008. (Measured urban bus acceleration profiles peaking at ±0.32g against a reported balance-loss threshold of 0.15g for a standing passenger using a handgrip. Maximum predicted probability of knee injury 53% and head injury 35%. Stairwells and horizontal seatback handles identified as particularly hazardous, with vertical handrails recommended in their place. Balance loss itself could not be predicted by the model.)
  • Silvano, A.P. and Ohlin, M., “Non-collision incidents on buses due to acceleration and braking manoeuvres leading to falling events among standing passengers”, Journal of Transport & Health, 2019. (Three and a half years of Swedish emergency department cases, all passengers standing when they fell. Under acceleration, passengers aged 65 and over most often fell immediately after boarding; braking showed a different pattern. Female involvement was high in younger age groups as well, which the authors suggest may indicate different balance thresholds by sex.)
  • Fruin, J.J., Huang, H.F., Zegeer, C. and Smith, N.E., “Recommendations for reducing noncollision bus passenger injuries”, Transportation Research Board, 1994. (More than 5,000 bus passenger injuries from the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority. One third occurred during boarding and alighting, a further quarter during stopping; 45% of injuries on stopping buses occurred while passengers were getting up, sitting down or seated; one third of alighting injuries were trips or slips. The rate fell by about a third between 1976 and 1990.)
  • Kendrick, D., Drummond, A., Logan, P., Barnes, J. and Worthington, E., “Systematic review of the epidemiology of non-collision injuries occurring to older people during use of public buses in high-income countries”, 2015. (Ten studies. More than 6,000 people a year injured on public buses in the UK, about half aged 65 or over. Older people and women over-represented; most injuries in daytime hours on weekdays, while standing and moving around the bus, boarding or alighting, and while the bus was accelerating or decelerating.)
  • Halpern, P. et al., “Non-collision injuries in public buses: a national survey of a neglected problem”, Emergency Medicine Journal, 2005. (Prospective study across six Israeli emergency departments. 120 patients, 86 women, over half older than 55. Main mechanism acceleration or deceleration, most standing. No fatalities; 17 admitted to hospital.)
  • Zhou, H., Chen, Y., Dong, N., Wong, S.C. and Xu, P., “Severity of passenger injuries on public buses: A comparative analysis of collision injuries and non-collision injuries”, Journal of Safety Research, 2020. (Police-reported data on 17,383 passengers injured on franchised public buses in Hong Kong over ten years. Random parameters logistic modelling found substantial inconsistencies in the effects of risk factors between non-collision and collision injury models.)
  • Berntman, M., Wretstrand, A. and Holmberg, B., “Bus travel safety — a travel chain perspective”, Lund University, 2010. (Argues that police-reported accident data covers bus occupant safety only, rarely the whole travel chain, and combines police and hospital registrations from four Swedish emergency departments to capture injuries to and from the stop as well as on board.)
  • Transport for London. Top tips for safer travel in London, Feb. 5, 2025. madeby.tfl.gov.uk.
  • London Assembly Transport Committee, March 2024. london.gov.uk.
  • FMCSA. Pre-trip Safety Information for Motorcoach Passengers, updated July 31, 2019. fmcsa.dot.gov.
  • Department for Transport. Reported road casualties Great Britain, final results: 2025, July 30, 2026. gov.uk.

Similar Posts