Crypto investing losses: what the evidence shows — ROR Labs cover showing 73–81% likely lost.
|

Crypto Investing Losses: What the Evidence Shows

Key takeaways · 11 min read

  • A BIS study estimated that 73% to 81% of retail bitcoin buyers had probably lost money on their first purchase by 2022.
  • Most buyers came after prices had risen: in one US bank’s data, the average purchase price was $43,900.
  • The same retail traders rebalance stocks but tend to chase crypto price rises.
  • Many smaller coins fail, and pump-and-dump schemes move money from outsiders to insiders.

Most people seem to know someone who got rich on cryptocurrency. Bitcoin went from almost nothing to more than $125,000 in October 2025, and anyone who bought early and held on made extraordinary returns. Less visible is who bought late, how much they put in, and what happened when prices fell, exchanges collapsed or a scammer got there first.

It can now be measured. Central bankers have tracked crypto app downloads in 95 countries, a large US bank has followed the transfers of millions of customers, and economists have compared how the same people trade shares and crypto on the same platform. Law enforcement publishes detailed loss figures every year.

The findings cut both ways. Most retail buyers in the studied periods probably lost money, mainly because they arrived after prices had already risen. But the most quoted loss estimates depend heavily on the date they were measured, and later price rises would have changed some of them. This article sets out what the evidence shows, and what it cannot show.

A pointillist illustration: a city street at night with a glowing amber cryptocurrency kiosk between dark shopfronts, a streetlamp and one passer-by.
A crypto kiosk at night. Losses at such machines are now tracked by the FBI.

How many retail investors lost money

In 2022, economists at the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), the central bankers’ bank, used daily data on crypto exchange app downloads and use in 95 countries from 2015 to 2022. Their working paper, by Raphael Auer and colleagues, estimated that 73% to 81% of retail investors had likely lost money on their initial bitcoin investment, and that about 40% of the new users were men under 35.

Timing explains it. Rising bitcoin prices were followed by waves of new users, and as they arrived, larger holders sold, which the authors described as larger holders likely making a return at retail users’ expense. A later BIS bulletin, published in February 2023 after the collapse of the Terra stablecoin and the FTX exchange, reached a similar conclusion with a simple simulation.

In the bulletin’s simulation, each new user bought $100 of bitcoin in the month they downloaded an app and $100 every month after that. By December 2022 the median investor would have lost $431 of the $900 they had put in. Almost three-quarters of users had downloaded their app when bitcoin was above $20,000, and in nearly every one of the 95 economies a majority of these investors probably lost money.

Around the two shocks, the same bulletin found the largest holders, with more than 1,000 bitcoin each, reducing their holdings while small holders (less than one bitcoin) and medium holders increased theirs. That is consistent with a transfer from late small buyers to early large ones.

The late buyer’s arithmetic

Simulation of retail bitcoin investors in 95 economies, marked to December 2022.

$431median loss on $900 invested, if $100 was bought at download and each month after
3 in 4users who downloaded a crypto app when bitcoin was above $20,000

Cornelli, Doerr, Frost and Gambacorta, BIS Bulletin No. 69, 2023. A simulation based on app data, not account records.

What American households did

Of almost 5 million active checking customers studied by the JPMorgan Chase Institute, more than 600,000 sent money to crypto accounts. The share who had ever done so rose from 3% before 2020 to 13% by June 2022. The typical person transferred money when bitcoin was trading at a weighted average of $43,900, and more than half made their average transfers above $40,000.

Lower-income customers bought at a higher average price ($45,400) than the highest earners ($42,400). Only 13% of people had taken out as much money as they had put in. Stakes were mostly modest, with a median net transfer of less than a week’s take-home pay, although almost 15% of users had transferred more than a month’s pay. Men were about twice as likely as women to buy.

Average bitcoin price when households bought

Transaction-weighted average bitcoin price at the time of transfers, US Chase customers, to mid-2022.

Lower-income customers$45,400
All customers$43,900
Highest earners$42,400

JPMorgan Chase Institute, 2022. Transfers only; the institute could not observe holdings or sales on the exchanges.

A 2025 update from the same institute put the share of active Chase customers who had invested in crypto between 2017 and May 2025 at 17%, and about 80% of them had transferred less than one month’s income. Among self-directed investors at J.P. Morgan Wealth Management, about 2% held crypto exchange-traded funds, with a median allocation under 5% of their assets.

Why crypto behaves differently

A pointillist illustration: a notebook page of handwritten lines beside a plain coin and a small padlock, lit by warm amber light.
Self-custody puts the risk in your own hands. The same traders treated crypto and shares in opposite ways.

One of the first systematic studies of crypto returns, by Yukun Liu and Aleh Tsyvinski, appeared in the Review of Financial Studies in 2021. Returns had little exposure to the factors that explain stock returns and were driven by factors specific to crypto, especially momentum and investor attention. In their working-paper data, a rise in Google searches for bitcoin predicted higher returns two weeks later.

A 2024 study in the Journal of Financial Economics by Shimon Kogan, Igor Makarov, Marina Niessner and Antoinette Schoar looked at 199,927 retail traders on the eToro platform from 2015 to 2019. The same people behaved in opposite ways in different markets: when a stock rose, they sold some to rebalance, and when a cryptocurrency rose, they bought more.

A 1% daily rise in a cryptocurrency’s price increased its share of the average portfolio by 0.67%, while a 1% rise in a stock reduced its share by 0.28%. Not even days of extreme moves prompted rebalancing in crypto, and behaviour did not change after the early 2018 crash, when bitcoin lost more than half its value. Crypto’s daily volatility was about twice that of stocks. The authors ruled out inattention, fees and lottery-seeking, and suggested that traders read rising prices as a signal of future adoption.

Same traders, two markets

Retail traders on one platform, 2015–2019.

AssetDaily volatilityResponse to a 1% price rise
Crypto (bitcoin, ether, XRP)5.3%Portfolio share rises 0.67%
Top 200 stocks2.7%Portfolio share falls 0.28%
Gold0.6%Traded against the trend

Kogan, Makarov, Niessner and Schoar, Journal of Financial Economics, 2024. One platform, mostly European users, many trades were contracts for difference.

Coins that disappear

Bitcoin has survived; most crypto assets have not. A 2021 study by Neil Gandal, JT Hamrick, Tyler Moore and Marie Vasek followed 1,082 coins and 725 tokens for more than four years and found that 44% of publicly traded coins had been abandoned at least temporarily. Many were later revived, but 18% failed permanently. Tokens built on other blockchains fared better, with 7% abandoned and 5% permanently failed.

Small coins carry another specific risk: manipulation. In a study published in the Review of Finance, Anirudh Dhawan and Tālis Putniņš identified 355 organised pump-and-dump schemes over six months, in which groups coordinated on messaging apps to buy a coin at a set time. The pumps produced average price distortions of 65%. A 2025 study in the Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis by Tao Li, Donghwa Shin and Baolian Wang found that prices often rose before the announced start, suggesting wealth transfers from outsiders to insiders.

What happens to coins

Publicly traded coins and tokens followed for more than four years.

Coins abandoned at least temporarily44%
Coins that failed permanently18%
Tokens abandoned at least temporarily7%
Tokens that failed permanently5%

Gandal, Hamrick, Moore and Vasek, Decisions in Economics and Finance, 2021. 1,082 coins and 725 tokens.

Platforms, fraud and leverage

Platform failure is a separate risk: customers can lose money whatever the coins are worth. The FTX exchange collapsed in November 2022. Its founder, Sam Bankman-Fried, was convicted of fraud in November 2023 and sentenced to 25 years in March 2024; prosecutors said he had stolen more than $8 billion of customers’ money. The crypto lender Celsius froze withdrawals in June 2022 with about $4.7 billion of assets belonging to some 400,000 customers, and its founder was sentenced to 12 years in May 2025.

Exchanges are still hacked: in February 2025 about $1.5 billion in crypto was stolen from the Bybit exchange, a hack the FBI attributed to North Korea. Fraud aimed directly at individuals is now larger than any single collapse. According to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center, Americans reported $11.4 billion in crypto-related losses in 2025, up 22% on 2024. Crypto investment fraud alone accounted for $7.2 billion. Victims aged over 60 reported $4.3 billion in crypto-related losses, and losses at crypto ATMs and kiosks reached $389 million.

Reported crypto-related losses in the US

Complaints to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center.

$9.3bncrypto-related losses reported in 2024
$11.4bncrypto-related losses reported in 2025, including $7.2bn in investment fraud

FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center annual reports, 2024 and 2025. Reported complaints only; many losses are never reported.

Many of these scams begin as relationships or investment tips and move victims onto fake trading platforms that show invented profits. We described how the script works in our article on romance-baiting scams. Leverage adds a third kind of loss. On 10 October 2025, after a US tariff announcement, more than $19 billion of leveraged crypto positions were liquidated within 24 hours, days after bitcoin had set a record above $125,000. By early February 2026, according to one asset manager’s market note, bitcoin had fallen about half from that peak.

What the loss estimates cannot show

The BIS figures are simulations and do not come from account records. They assume users bought on the day they downloaded an app, ignore sales and fees, and cover only bitcoin, and the bulletin marked the results in December 2022, near a low point. Bitcoin later rose far above the prices at which most of those users arrived, so a calculation run in October 2025 would very likely have shown many of the same simulated investors in profit. That is our inference, not the BIS’s, and it shows how much the answer depends on the date.

Studies of small allocations also disagree. Marie Brière, Kim Oosterlinck and Ariane Szafarz found in 2015 that even a small allocation to bitcoin improved a diversified portfolio’s risk-return trade-off, while warning that their data from 2010 to 2013 might reflect early-stage behaviour that would not last. In 2020, Thomas Conlon and Richard McGee found that during the COVID-19 crash even a small allocation to bitcoin substantially increased a portfolio’s downside risk.

The SEC approved spot bitcoin exchange-traded products in January 2024, letting investors hold bitcoin exposure through ordinary brokerage accounts. The then chair, Gary Gensler, said the approval was not an endorsement and described bitcoin as primarily a speculative, volatile asset. Funds of this kind remove the risk of an exchange collapse or a lost password, but they do nothing about price.

A pointillist illustration: a person in a dark room facing a laptop whose price line rises to a peak and then falls, an amber floor lamp behind.
A price line that rises and falls. Most estimated losses depend on when the buyer arrived.

A worked example: what a 50% fall takes to recover

Loss estimates are easy to read and hard to feel, so this section does the arithmetic on a single holding and then lists what the SEC, FTC and FBI say about protection and reporting. The recovery arithmetic is ours; no official page we read states it.

Say you hold $10,000 of a coin and it falls 50%. You now have $5,000. To get back to $10,000 it must rise not 50% but 100%, because the gain is measured on the smaller amount.

The gain needed to get back to $10,000 (illustrative arithmetic)
FallLeft of $10,000Gain needed to recover
20%$8,00025%
50%$5,000100%
80%$2,000400%
90%$1,000900%

What protects you, and what does not. The SEC’s investor alert (23 March 2023) says broker-dealer customers generally have SIPC protection and bank deposits are FDIC-insured up to a limit, but accounts placed with crypto asset entities have no such protections. The FTC (page updated 10 February 2025) says crypto accounts are not insured like bank deposits and crypto payments typically cannot be reversed.

If you were scammed, step by step. The FBI’s page says to stop sending money and file a report with the Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) or your local FBI field office. Include how the scammer contacted you, names, phone numbers, emails and usernames, payment dates and amounts, receiving wallet addresses, transaction IDs, websites or apps used, and a timeline; submit what you have even if it is incomplete. Do not pay “taxes” or “fees” to unlock funds, and be wary of anyone who offers to recover your losses.

Where to report. The FTC page lists ReportFraud.ftc.gov, CFTC.gov/complaint, sec.gov/tcr, ic3.gov and the exchange you used to send the money.

What we could not confirm. We did not fetch IC3’s own pages, so the filing steps above come from the FBI page. We did not fetch the FTC loss statistics; the figures earlier in this post come from the FBI.

What the evidence suggests

The same pattern appears across very different data sources. Retail investors tended to arrive after prices had already risen sharply, often with money they could not easily afford, and larger holders sold to them. Most coins other than the largest have a high chance of disappearing. For many Americans, fraud is now the largest crypto loss, ahead of any market crash.

The Federal Reserve’s survey of household economic well-being found that 10% of US adults used crypto in 2025, most of them as an investment. For readers who hold some, the research suggests four questions: when did I buy relative to the price, what share of my savings is this, who holds the coins, and how would I know if the platform showing my balance was real? Our article on deposit insurance explains what that protection does and does not cover.

What to do

These are checks, not investment recommendations. Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

Before

  • Ask when you bought relative to the price, and what share of your savings this is. Untested see Sources
  • Ask who actually holds the coins, and how you would know if the platform showing your balance were real. Untested see Sources

What not to do

  • Do not trust a trading platform introduced through a new relationship or an investment tip. Americans reported $7.2 billion lost to crypto investment fraud in 2025. Measured see Sources
  • Do not assume deposit insurance covers coins on a platform. When a platform fails, customers can lose money whatever the coins are worth. Official advice see Sources

Not financial advice.

Questions people ask

What percentage of crypto investors lose money?

A 2022 BIS working paper estimated that 73% to 81% of retail bitcoin investors in 95 countries had likely lost money on their initial investment. The estimate depends on the date prices were measured.

Why do most people lose money on crypto?

The studies point mainly to timing: new users arrived after prices had risen, and larger holders sold to them.

How much money is lost to crypto scams?

Americans reported $11.4 billion in crypto-related losses to the FBI in 2025, including $7.2 billion in crypto investment fraud.

Are bitcoin ETFs safer than buying crypto directly?

They remove the risk of an exchange failing or losing access to a wallet, but not the risk of price falls.

How many cryptocurrencies fail?

In one study, 44% of publicly traded coins were abandoned at least temporarily and 18% failed permanently over about four years.

The short version

  • A BIS study estimated that 73% to 81% of retail bitcoin buyers had probably lost money on their first purchase by 2022.
  • Most buyers came after prices had risen: in one US bank’s data, the average purchase price was $43,900.
  • The same retail traders rebalance stocks but tend to chase crypto price rises.
  • Many smaller coins fail, and pump-and-dump schemes move money from outsiders to insiders.
  • Reported US crypto fraud losses reached $11.4 billion in 2025, and loss estimates change sharply with the date they are measured.

This article summarises published research and official data on cryptocurrency losses. It is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice, and it does not recommend buying or selling any crypto asset, fund or platform. Crypto assets can lose all their value. If you think you have been targeted by a scam, report it to the police and, in the United States, to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center.

Further reading. Cornelli, Doerr, Frost and Gambacorta, ‘Crypto shocks and retail losses’, BIS Bulletin No. 69, 2023, is short and readable. Kogan, Makarov, Niessner and Schoar, Journal of Financial Economics, 2024, explains why the same people treat crypto differently.

Sources

  1. Auer R, Cornelli G, Doerr S, Frost J, Gambacorta L. Crypto trading and Bitcoin prices: evidence from a new database of retail adoption. BIS Working Papers No. 1049, 2022; published in IMF Economic Review, 2026;74(2):425–460. doi:10.1057/s41308-025-00275-0.
  2. Cornelli G, Doerr S, Frost J, Gambacorta L. Crypto shocks and retail losses. BIS Bulletin No. 69, February 2023.
  3. Wheat C, Eckerd G. The dynamics and demographics of U.S. household crypto-asset use. JPMorgan Chase Institute, December 2022.
  4. JPMorgan Chase Institute. Crypto investor waves since 2017. August 2025.
  5. Liu Y, Tsyvinski A. Risks and returns of cryptocurrency. Review of Financial Studies, 2021;34(6):2689–2727. doi:10.1093/rfs/hhaa113.
  6. Kogan S, Makarov I, Niessner M, Schoar A. Are cryptos different? Evidence from retail trading. Journal of Financial Economics, 2024;159:103897. doi:10.1016/j.jfineco.2024.103897.
  7. Gandal N, Hamrick JT, Moore T, Vasek M. The rise and fall of cryptocurrency coins and tokens. Decisions in Economics and Finance, 2021;44(2):981–1014. doi:10.1007/s10203-021-00329-8.
  8. Dhawan A, Putniņš TJ. A new wolf in town? Pump-and-dump manipulation in cryptocurrency markets. Review of Finance, 2023;27(3):935–975. doi:10.1093/rof/rfac051.
  9. Li T, Shin D, Wang B. Cryptocurrency pump-and-dump schemes. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 2025;60(8):3622–3659. doi:10.1017/S0022109025000201.
  10. Brière M, Oosterlinck K, Szafarz A. Virtual currency, tangible return: portfolio diversification with bitcoin. Journal of Asset Management, 2015;16(6):365–373. doi:10.1057/jam.2015.5.
  11. Conlon T, McGee R. Safe haven or risky hazard? Bitcoin during the Covid-19 bear market. Finance Research Letters, 2020;35:101607. doi:10.1016/j.frl.2020.101607.
  12. Federal Bureau of Investigation, Internet Crime Complaint Center. Internet Crime Report 2024 and Internet Crime Report 2025.
  13. Federal Bureau of Investigation. North Korea responsible for $1.5 billion Bybit hack. Public service announcement, 26 February 2025.
  14. US Department of Justice, Southern District of New York. Samuel Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years. March 2024; Alex Mashinsky sentenced to 12 years. May 2025.
  15. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2025. May 2026.
  16. Gensler G. Statement on the approval of spot bitcoin exchange-traded products. US Securities and Exchange Commission, 10 January 2024.
  17. CoinDesk Research. Analysis of the 10 October 2025 crypto liquidation event, citing CoinGlass data. October 2025.
  18. SEC Office of Investor Education. “Exercise Caution with Crypto Asset Securities: Investor Alert” (23 March 2023).
  19. FTC. “What To Know About Cryptocurrency and Scams” (updated 10 February 2025).
  20. FBI. “Cryptocurrency Investment Fraud”.

Similar Posts