Workplace bullying: what the evidence shows — ROR Labs cover showing 14.6% bullied.
|

Workplace Bullying: What the Evidence Shows

Key takeaways · 11 min read

  • In pooled studies, about 11% to 18% of workers report bullying, though the figure depends heavily on how the question is asked.
  • Bullying predicts later anxiety and depression, and poor mental health in turn predicts later bullying.
  • Few anti-bullying interventions have been tested well, and the Cochrane review rated the evidence very low quality.
  • Organisation-wide programmes led from the top look more promising than one-off training.

Workplace bullying rarely looks dramatic. It is a manager who criticises every piece of work in front of colleagues, a team that stops inviting one person to meetings, a stream of impossible deadlines, jokes that are never quite jokes. Any one of these can be shrugged off. Repetition over months turns them into bullying, as the target finds it harder and harder to defend themselves.

Researchers in Scandinavia began studying it systematically in the late 1980s, and the field now spans dozens of countries. Bullied employees are clearly more likely to become anxious, depressed and ill. On other points the results are surprisingly unsettled. How common bullying is depends heavily on how the question is asked, poor mental health also seems to make people more likely to be bullied later, and there is very little good evidence that the anti-bullying programmes employers buy actually work.

This article looks at what the evidence shows about how often bullying happens, what it does to people, which way the arrows point, and what has been tested as a remedy.

What counts as bullying

Most researchers use a definition developed in Norway and Britain: bullying is repeated and persistent negative treatment, usually over at least six months, that the target finds hard to stop because of an imbalance of power. By this definition a single conflict, however unpleasant, does not count, and neither does a disagreement between equals who both give as good as they get.

The negative acts fall into two broad groups. Work-related bullying includes excessive monitoring, withholding information, unreasonable workloads and constant criticism; person-related bullying includes humiliation, gossip, social exclusion and insulting remarks. Physical intimidation is the least common form. Most bullying comes from people with more power, often a direct manager, but peers and even subordinates can be the source.

How common it is depends on the question

In 2010, Morten Birkeland Nielsen, Stig Berge Matthiesen and Ståle Einarsen pooled 102 prevalence estimates from 86 samples covering 130,973 workers. The average was 14.6%. But the method mattered a great deal.

Workers who were given a definition of bullying and asked whether it applied to them said yes in 11.3% of cases. Asked about specific negative acts, such as being ignored or humiliated, with a threshold applied by researchers, 14.8% qualified. Asked whether they had been bullied with no definition given, 18.1% said so. Studies with non-random samples reported rates 8.7 percentage points higher than random ones.

How the question changes the answer

Share of workers classed as bullied, by measurement method. 86 samples, 130,973 workers.

Self-labelled, definition given11.3%
All methods, average14.6%
Specific negative acts, threshold14.8%
Self-labelled, no definition18.1%

Nielsen MB, Matthiesen SB, Einarsen S, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2010;83(4):955–979.

A pointillist illustration: an open-plan office at the end of the day, rows of empty desks and one occupied desk under a single amber lamp, a small group of colleagues standing together by the far windows.
An office at the end of the day. Exclusion is one of the most common forms of bullying.

The same effect shows up inside a single survey. A representative study of 2,539 Norwegian employees, published in 2009, produced estimates from 2% to 14.3% depending on the method. The researchers judged a statistical method called latent class cluster analysis the most reliable, giving 6.8%. Only 2% described themselves as victims of severe bullying.

International surveys use broader definitions. In 2022 the International Labour Organization, Lloyd’s Register Foundation and Gallup published the first global survey of violence and harassment at work, based on interviews in 121 countries. It found that 22.8% of people in employment had experienced at least one form in their working life, and psychological violence and harassment, at 17.9%, was the most common. That figure includes single incidents, so it cannot be compared directly with the research definition of bullying.

Violence and harassment at work, worldwide

First global survey, 121 countries, people in employment.

22.8%had experienced violence or harassment at work in their working life
54.4%of those affected had ever told anyone about it

International Labour Organization, Lloyd’s Register Foundation and Gallup, 2022. Includes single incidents, so it is broader than the research definition of bullying.

Nearly half of those affected had never told anyone, and the survey’s most common reasons were that it would be a waste of time and fear for their reputation. Whatever the true rate of bullying, official complaints capture only part of it.

One survey, several answers

Norwegian employees, representative sample of 2,539, by estimation method.

MethodShare bullied
Self-labelled victims of severe bullying2.0%
Self-reported victimisation4.6%
Latent class cluster analysis6.8%
Broadest operational method14.3%

Nielsen MB et al, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2009;18(1):81–101.

What bullying does to people

Cross-sectional evidence is extensive. In a 2012 meta-analysis in Work & Stress, Nielsen and Einarsen combined 137 effect sizes from 66 samples with 77,721 people. Exposure to bullying was associated with mental and physical health problems, symptoms of post-traumatic stress, burnout, intentions to leave, and lower job satisfaction and commitment. Links with absenteeism, performance and sleep were weak or not significant.

Cross-sectional studies cannot show direction. A person who is already depressed might perceive colleagues as more hostile, or might become an easier target. The same meta-analysis therefore also examined 13 longitudinal samples with 62,916 people, followed over time. Bullying predicted later mental health problems, and mental health problems at the start also predicted later reports of being bullied, to a similar degree.

A pointillist illustration: a single office chair pushed back from a desk, a closed laptop and a coat still hanging on the chair, lit by a tall amber lamp.
An empty chair with a coat on it. Bullying predicts later health problems, and the reverse.

A 2014 meta-analysis of prospective studies in the journal of the Norwegian Medical Association put numbers on this two-way relationship. Exposure to bullying raised the odds of later mental health problems by about two thirds, with an odds ratio of 1.68, and of later somatic symptoms, with an odds ratio of 1.77. Mental health problems raised the odds of later exposure to bullying by a similar amount, 1.74.

The authors did not conclude that bullying is harmless. They described a vicious circle: being bullied makes people ill, being ill makes them more vulnerable to being singled out, and each worsens the other. That matters for how organisations respond. Treating a bullied employee’s distress as evidence that they are the problem gets the causal story half right and the moral story wrong.

Which way do the arrows point?

Pooled odds ratios from prospective studies of workplace bullying and health.

1.68odds of later mental health problems after exposure to bullying
1.74odds of later bullying after earlier mental health problems

Nielsen MB, Magerøy N, Gjerstad J, Einarsen S, Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, 2014;134(12–13):1233–1238. Somatic symptoms: 1.77.

What has been tried, and what the trials show

Employers have many options: policies, training for managers, awareness campaigns, confidential reporting routes, mediation, investigation and disciplinary procedures. Very few have been tested properly.

In 2014, Margaret Hodgins, Sarah MacCurtain and Patricia Mannix-McNamara searched 11 databases and 5,364 records for evaluated interventions against workplace bullying or incivility. Only 12 had been published in peer-reviewed journals. Eight were so weak in design that the reviewers classed them as inconclusive, including every observational and uncontrolled before-and-after study, and only three reached a moderate quality rating.

The Cochrane Collaboration reached a similar verdict. Its review of interventions to prevent workplace bullying, led by Patricia Gillen and updated in 2017, found only a handful of eligible studies and rated the evidence as very low quality. In Work & Stress, a 2024 meta-analysis of 19 studies by Alfredo Rodríguez-Muñoz and colleagues found that interventions such as cognitive rehearsal, education and training for supervisors were associated with fewer bullying incidents. The authors warned of a high risk of bias and a possible Hawthorne effect, in which people behave differently simply because they know they are being studied.

One early evaluation shows why caution is needed. A six-month programme in five UK public sector organisations, reported by Helge Hoel and Sabir Giga in 2006 and described in a later review by Iain Coyne and Marilyn Campbell, combined policy communication with stress awareness and training about negative behaviour. Reported bullying rose slightly, from 13.6% to 14.3%. Training can make people better at recognising bullying, which may raise reported rates even if actual behaviour improves.

The evidence on anti-bullying interventions at work

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses.

ReviewStudiesVerdict
Hodgins and colleagues, 201412 appraised8 inconclusive, 3 of moderate quality
Cochrane, Gillen and colleagues, 2017A handfulVery low quality evidence
Rodríguez-Muñoz and colleagues, 202419Some reductions; high risk of bias

Hodgins M et al, Int J Workplace Health Manag, 2014;7(1):54–72; Gillen PA et al, Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2017; Rodríguez-Muñoz A et al, Work & Stress, 2024.

The more recent reviews point to a pattern rather than a single answer. Programmes that are organisation-wide, supported by senior leaders, run for a long time and change how work is organised seem more promising than one-off training for individuals. That fits what researchers have long found about the causes of bullying: role conflict, heavy workloads, poor leadership and restructuring all raise the risk.

Why some workplaces have more of it

Early explanations focused on difficult bosses and vulnerable victims. Since the 1990s, research summarised by Ståle Einarsen, Helge Hoel, Dieter Zapf and Cary Cooper has put more weight on the work environment. Bullying is more common where roles are unclear or contradictory, workloads are heavy, leaders avoid dealing with conflict, and organisations are going through cuts or restructuring.

This is sometimes called the work environment hypothesis. It does not excuse individual behaviour, but it explains why bullying clusters in some teams and not others, and why replacing one bully sometimes changes little. Where stress is high and nobody enforces standards, hostile behaviour can become a way of coping, competing or passing pressure down the line.

A common employer response, sending the target or the accused on a course, tends to disappoint for the same reason. If the conditions that produced the bullying stay the same, the pattern can resume with different people. The more promising programmes in the reviews treated bullying as a feature of how the organisation works, as well as a problem between two individuals.

A pointillist illustration: a long corridor of closed office doors with frosted glass, one door at the end slightly open with warm amber light spilling out.
A corridor of closed doors. Most bullying comes from someone with more power.

A recent case

In April 2023 the UK deputy prime minister Dominic Raab resigned after an independent investigation by the lawyer Adam Tolley found that he had acted in an intimidating way towards civil servants on some occasions. Raab disputed the findings and argued that the threshold for bullying had been set too low. Even after a formal inquiry, the line between demanding management and bullying remained contested, and much depended on the definition applied.

Legal protection varies widely by country. France and Sweden, among others, have specific laws or regulations covering moral or psychological harassment at work. Many others, including the United Kingdom and most US states, have no general law against workplace bullying, so targets must rely on discrimination, harassment, health and safety or constructive dismissal rules, which cover only some situations.

What this means if it is happening to you

The research suggests three practical points. First, keep a record: dates, what was said or done, who saw it, and any emails or messages. Bullying is a pattern, and patterns are hard to prove from memory. Second, look after your health early. The link between bullying and later depression runs in both directions, so getting support is no sign of weakness and may break the cycle. Third, find out what your organisation’s procedure actually is and who, apart from the person involved, can act on it.

Leaving is sometimes the right answer, and the evidence does not suggest that people who stay and endure recover by themselves. For the wider link between work and health, see our article on long working hours and burnout.

For managers, the cheapest intervention is to deal with conflict early and fairly, set clear roles and realistic workloads, and treat a complaint as information about the team rather than a nuisance. Surveys that ask about specific behaviours, as well as the word ‘bullying’, give a truer picture of what is happening.

What the official pages say about workplace bullying

Official pages in the UK, US and the ILO frame bullying differently: as a stress and management issue, as violence, or as harassment. This section sets out what each page says.

Source and what it says
SourceWhat it says
Acas, UK government-funded advisory body, What bullying is (last updated December 16, 2025)There is no legal definition of bullying. It describes unwanted behaviour that offends, intimidates, insults or misuses power, whether one-off or a pattern, in person or online. Employers should take complaints seriously, investigate as soon as possible and recognise their duty of care.
GOV.UK (UK government), Workplace bullying and harassment (no date in the visible text; metadata shows first published 2012, last public update 2016)Bullying alone is not unlawful; harassment is unlawful when tied to a protected characteristic. Employers must work to prevent it and are liable for harassment employees suffer.
Health and Safety Executive (UK government), Management Standards: Relationships (updated May 11, 2021)The standard is that employees say they are not subjected to unacceptable behaviours such as bullying. Employers should promote positive behaviour, have agreed policies, help managers deal with it and have reporting systems.
OSHA (US government), Workplace Violence fact sheet (October 2024)Defines workplace violence as any act or threat of violence against workers, including threats and verbal abuse. It does not mention bullying or harassment and states it imposes no new compliance requirements.
International Labour Organization (intergovernmental), Convention No. 190 and Recommendation No. 206 at a glance (adopted June 2019)Defines violence and harassment as a range of unacceptable behaviours or threats, single or repeated, that cause or are likely to cause physical, psychological, sexual or economic harm. Employers should adopt a policy with worker consultation, include these risks in occupational safety management and give training, as far as reasonably practicable.
Our comparisonThe UK pages say bullying has no legal definition, OSHA covers violence and threats but does not name bullying, and the ILO convention covers a broad set of unacceptable behaviours. HSE treats bullying as a stress-management issue. This means the same conduct can be handled under different rules depending on the country.

We could not confirm the ILO convention’s entry-into-force date or number of ratifications, the OSHA General Duty Clause (it is not in the fact sheet), or a US federal definition of bullying. An Acas page dated October 30, 2026 on preventing harassment lists no steps specific to bullying. Figures were read through automated page fetches, so confirm exact numbers on the live pages.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

If it happens

  • Keep a record: dates, what was said or done, who saw it, and any emails or messages. Patterns are hard to prove from memory. Untested see Sources
  • Look after your health early. The link runs both ways: bullying raised the odds of later mental health problems (1.68), and those problems raised the odds of later bullying (1.74). Measured see Sources
  • Find out what your organisation’s procedure actually is, and who, apart from the person involved, can act on it. Untested see Sources

Afterwards

  • Leaving is sometimes the right answer. The evidence does not suggest that people who stay and endure recover by themselves. Untested see Sources
  • As a manager: deal with conflict early and fairly, set clear roles and realistic workloads, and treat a complaint as information about the team. Untested see Sources

Not legal or medical advice. If it is affecting your health, talk to a doctor.

Questions people ask

How common is workplace bullying?

About 11% to 18% of workers in pooled studies, depending on the method. Rigorous estimates in single countries are often lower, around 5% to 7%.

What is the difference between bullying and conflict?

Bullying is repeated over months, and the target finds it hard to defend themselves because of a power imbalance. A one-off clash between equals is not bullying.

Does workplace bullying cause depression?

Prospective studies show that bullying predicts later mental health problems, with an odds ratio of about 1.7. Earlier mental health problems also predict later bullying.

Do anti-bullying programmes work?

The evidence is weak. Reviews found few well-designed studies; some programmes reduced reported bullying, but the risk of bias was high.

Is workplace bullying illegal?

It depends on the country. Some have specific laws; others cover it only when it overlaps with discrimination, harassment or safety law.

The short version

  • In pooled studies, about 11% to 18% of workers report bullying, though the figure depends heavily on how the question is asked.
  • Bullying predicts later anxiety and depression, and poor mental health in turn predicts later bullying.
  • Few anti-bullying interventions have been tested well, and the Cochrane review rated the evidence very low quality.
  • Organisation-wide programmes led from the top look more promising than one-off training.
  • Keeping a record and seeking support early are the most useful steps for targets.

This article summarises published research on workplace bullying. It is not legal or medical advice and is not a tool for assessing a specific situation. If bullying is affecting your health, speak to a doctor or a qualified counsellor, and for legal questions seek advice from a trade union, an employment adviser or a lawyer in your country.

Further reading. Nielsen and Einarsen, ‘Outcomes of exposure to workplace bullying: A meta-analytic review’, Work & Stress, 2012, is the key synthesis. Hodgins and colleagues, 2014, explains why so little is known about what works.

Sources

  1. Nielsen MB, Matthiesen SB, Einarsen S. The impact of methodological moderators on prevalence rates of workplace bullying: a meta-analysis. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2010;83(4):955–979. doi:10.1348/096317909X481256.
  2. Nielsen MB, Skogstad A, Matthiesen SB, and colleagues. Prevalence of workplace bullying in Norway: comparisons across time and estimation methods. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2009;18(1):81–101. doi:10.1080/13594320801969707.
  3. Nielsen MB, Einarsen S. Outcomes of exposure to workplace bullying: a meta-analytic review. Work & Stress, 2012;26(4):309–332. doi:10.1080/02678373.2012.734709.
  4. Nielsen MB, Magerøy N, Gjerstad J, Einarsen S. Workplace bullying and subsequent health problems. Tidsskrift for Den norske legeforening, 2014;134(12–13):1233–1238. doi:10.4045/tidsskr.13.0880.
  5. Hodgins M, MacCurtain S, Mannix-McNamara P. Workplace bullying and incivility: a systematic review of interventions. International Journal of Workplace Health Management, 2014;7(1):54–72. doi:10.1108/IJWHM-08-2013-0030.
  6. Gillen PA, Sinclair M, Kernohan WG, and colleagues. Interventions for prevention of bullying in the workplace. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017;(1):CD009778. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD009778.pub2.
  7. Rodríguez-Muñoz A, Díaz-Guerra A, Antino M, and colleagues. Interventions against bullying at work: a meta-analysis. Work & Stress, 2025;39(1):1–30. doi:10.1080/02678373.2024.2435677.
  8. Einarsen S, Hoel H, Zapf D, Cooper CL, eds. Bullying and Harassment in the Workplace: Developments in Theory, Research, and Practice. 2nd ed. CRC Press, 2011.
  9. Coyne I, Campbell M. Preventing bullying in school and work contexts. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 2017. doi:10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.013.14.
  10. International Labour Organization, Lloyd’s Register Foundation, Gallup. Experiences of Violence and Harassment at Work: A Global First Survey. ILO, 2022.
  11. Tolley A. Investigation into formal complaints about the conduct of the Rt Hon Dominic Raab MP. UK Cabinet Office, April 2023.
  12. Acas: Bullying at work; GOV.UK: Workplace bullying and harassment; HSE: Relationships standard; OSHA: Workplace violence; ILO: Convention 190 at a glance.

Similar Posts