Cover: 27% of households. Utility shutoffs and energy insecurity, what the evidence shows.
|

Utility Shutoffs and Energy Insecurity: What the Evidence Shows

Key takeaways · 11 min read

  • In 2020, 27% of US households, 34 million, had difficulty meeting their energy needs.
  • In both the US and UK, poor households cut food spending during unusually cold weather.
  • Young children in severely energy-insecure homes had about three times the odds of food insecurity.
  • Across US counties, utility disconnection moratoria were estimated to cut COVID-19 deaths by 7.4%.

A power cut caused by a storm is news, and one caused by an unpaid bill is not. It happens quietly, one household at a time, usually after a series of notices, and it can leave a family without heating, cooling, refrigeration or the electricity that runs a medical device.

Researchers call the wider problem energy insecurity: being unable to meet a household’s basic energy needs. It includes struggling to pay bills, keeping a home at an unsafe temperature to save money, and being disconnected. It is far more common than most people assume, and it tends to hit the same households that struggle with rent, food and medical bills.

This article covers what the evidence shows about how many households are affected, what it does to health, whether protections against disconnection work, and where the research is still thin. The starting number comes from the US Energy Information Administration: in 2020, 27% of American households, 34 million, reported difficulty meeting their energy needs.

How many households are affected?

The US Energy Information Administration runs the Residential Energy Consumption Survey, which gives the best national data. In its 2020 round, 34 million households, 27% of the total, reported difficulty paying energy bills or keeping their home at a safe temperature because of cost, down from 31% in 2015.

The survey breaks this down further. About 10% of households received a disconnection notice in 2020, down from 14% in 2015. Around 5 million could not use their heating equipment because it was broken and they could not afford repairs or fuel, and around 6 million could not use their air conditioning for the same reasons. About 1.4 million households, 1%, reported that someone needed medical attention because their home was too hot or too cold.

Energy insecurity was higher among lower-income households, families with children, renters, and Black and Hispanic households. The EIA has also reported that energy-insecure households tend to be billed more per unit of floor space, often because they live in older, less efficient homes.

Energy insecurity in US homes, 2020

Households reporting each problem, Residential Energy Consumption Survey.

Any difficulty meeting energy needs (34m)27%
Received a disconnection notice10%
Someone needed medical attention1%

US Energy Information Administration, ‘In 2020, 27% of U.S. households had difficulty meeting their energy needs’, 2022.

A pointillist illustration: an apartment block at dusk with rows of lit windows, one window dark except for the small amber glow of a candle.
An apartment block at dusk. One window lit only by a candle.

Heat or eat

Something else has to give when energy bills rise, and for poor households it is often food.

Jayanta Bhattacharya, Thomas DeLeire, Steven Haider and Janet Currie studied this in the United States. During cold-weather budget shocks, they found, poor parents and their children spent less on food and ate less, and existing social programmes did not fully protect them. They called it the heat or eat dilemma.

The analysis, published in the American Journal of Public Health in 2003, found the effect with a drop of only 10°F below normal temperatures. Poor families reduced food spending by roughly the same amount as their fuel spending rose, and poor adults and children took in roughly 200 fewer calories a day during winter months. Richer families, by contrast, increased their food spending. The fall in food spending was largest outside the South.

Timothy Beatty, Laura Blow and Thomas Crossley tested the same idea in the United Kingdom, using decades of household spending records merged with local weather data. The poorest older households could not smooth their spending when the weather turned unusually cold. Their food spending fell significantly in months two or more standard deviations colder than expected, which happen about one winter month in forty, and the cuts were larger in poorer households. Better-off households spent more on food in cold weather.

Families also describe choosing between energy bills and medicine, rent, or phone bills, so the trade-off goes beyond heating and food. In hot weather, the same arithmetic applies to air conditioning.

Heat or eat, in two countries

What unusually cold weather does to food in poor households.

~200fewer calories a day for poor US adults and children in winter months
1 in 40winter months cold enough for the poorest older UK households to cut food spending

Bhattacharya J and colleagues, American Journal of Public Health, 2003; Beatty TKM and colleagues, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A, 2014.

Three kinds of insecurity

Diana Hernández, a sociologist at Columbia University, has argued that energy insecurity has three dimensions. In a widely cited 2016 paper in Social Science and Medicine, she described an economic dimension, the cost of energy relative to income; a physical dimension, the condition of the home, its insulation, heating system and appliances; and a behavioural dimension, the ways people cope.

Some of the most direct health risks lie in the behavioural dimension. To save money or keep warm after a disconnection, households may use ovens or unvented space heaters for heat, run extension cords from neighbours, or use candles for light. Each carries its own risks of fire, burns and carbon monoxide poisoning.

The physical dimension explains why income alone does not account for energy insecurity. A household in a draughty older home with an inefficient boiler can spend a far larger share of its income on energy than a neighbour on the same income in a newer building. Weatherisation programmes, which insulate and repair homes, are often grouped with bill assistance for that reason.

What it does to children

The most cited study of energy insecurity and child health comes from Children’s HealthWatch, a network of paediatric researchers in emergency departments and clinics.

A pointillist illustration: an electricity meter on a pale wall, its dial dark and a small amber tag hanging from it.
A meter with a tag on it. One in ten US households received a disconnection notice in 2020.

In Pediatrics in 2008, John Cook and colleagues surveyed the caregivers of 9,721 children under three years old at five urban medical centres in Baltimore, Boston, Little Rock, Minneapolis and Philadelphia between 2001 and 2006. They classified 11% of households as moderately energy insecure and 23% as severely energy insecure.

After adjusting for other factors, children in severely energy-insecure households had about three times the odds of household food insecurity, and about three and a half times the odds of child food insecurity, compared with those in energy-secure homes. They were more likely to be reported in fair or poor health and to be flagged for developmental concerns. In moderately energy-insecure households, a child had higher odds of having been hospitalised since birth.

The study was cross-sectional, so it cannot show that energy insecurity caused these outcomes, and families that struggle with energy bills often struggle with much else. It did establish energy insecurity as a distinct hardship, separate from food insecurity, that paediatricians could screen for.

Energy insecurity and young children

Adjusted odds compared with energy-secure households, children under 3.

OutcomeModerate insecuritySevere insecurity
Household food insecurity2.373.06
Child food insecurity1.793.46
Fair or poor health1.341.36
Developmental riskno difference1.82

Cook JT and colleagues, Pediatrics, 2008. 9,721 children at five urban medical centres, 2001 to 2006.

Do shutoff protections work?

Most US states have some rules limiting disconnections, such as bans during extreme cold or heat, or protections for households with a medical certificate. Matthew Flaherty, Sanya Carley and David Konisky have documented how much these rules vary between states, and how small differences in design can produce large differences in who is protected.

The COVID-19 pandemic created a natural experiment: many states imposed temporary moratoria on utility disconnections in spring 2020, then lifted them at different times.

In a 2021 National Bureau of Economic Research working paper, Kay Jowers and colleagues used this variation across US counties. They estimated that utility disconnection moratoria reduced COVID-19 infection rates by 4.4% and death rates by 7.4%. Had such moratoria applied nationwide from March to November 2020, they estimated, infections could have been 8.7% lower and deaths 14.8% lower. Eviction moratoria had similar or larger effects.

Using the same state-by-state variation, Trevor Memmott, Sanya Carley, Michelle Graff and David Konisky looked at household outcomes in iScience in 2023. Protections reduced disconnections and reduced the need for households to forgo other essentials, with the largest benefits for people of colour and households with young children.

Utility disconnection moratoria and COVID-19

Estimated effects across US counties, March to November 2020.

Reduction in infections4.4%
Reduction in deaths7.4%
Deaths, if applied nationwide14.8%

Jowers K and colleagues, National Bureau of Economic Research working paper 28394, 2021.

Help with bills, and what happened to it

The Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program, or LIHEAP, is the main federal support in the United States. It received about $4.1 billion in fiscal year 2024 and helps roughly six million low-income households a year pay heating and cooling bills, though it reaches only a fraction of the households that qualify.

On 1 April 2025, as part of wider staff cuts at the Department of Health and Human Services, the entire federal staff that ran LIHEAP was laid off. Energy assistance groups warned that about $378 million of already-approved money had not yet been sent to states, and the administration’s budget request for the following year proposed ending the programme.

Congress continued to fund it. A federal government shutdown ran into November 2025, and HHS then released $3.6 billion for the 2026 heating season on 1 December 2025, later than usual. About two-thirds of LIHEAP recipients also receive food assistance, which was disrupted during the same shutdown.

For a family relying on assistance to keep the heat on, a few weeks’ delay can mean a disconnection notice instead of a warm home. The episode showed how exposed energy-insecure households are to decisions far away from them.

The Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program

Federal support for home energy bills in the United States.

~6 millionhouseholds helped each year
$4.1bnfederal funding in fiscal year 2024

Utility Dive, April 2025; LeadingAge, December 2025. All LIHEAP federal staff were laid off on 1 April 2025.

A pointillist illustration: a kitchen table at night with a stack of letters, the top envelope marked with an amber band, beside a single lit candle.
An envelope with an amber band. Final notices usually arrive before the power goes.

The other side of the argument

Utilities and some regulators argue that disconnection is a necessary last resort. When customers do not pay, the costs are usually spread across everyone else’s bills, including other low-income customers, and blanket bans on disconnection, they argue, can let debts build up to levels that households can never repay.

Researchers such as Carley and Konisky take that concern seriously, and it is one reason they favour targeted protections, such as bans during dangerous weather, medical exemptions and bill assistance, over indefinite moratoria.

The evidence on health effects also has limits. The Jowers study is observational, comparing counties that did and did not have protections at different times, and other policies changed at the same time. The Cook study is cross-sectional. Few studies follow households through a disconnection and measure what happens to their health afterwards.

Other countries show that the alternative to disconnection can carry its own problems. In Britain, suppliers can switch customers in arrears to prepayment meters, which cut off supply automatically when credit runs out. After a newspaper investigation in early 2023 revealed that agents working for a supplier had forced entry into vulnerable customers’ homes to fit such meters, the energy regulator Ofgem told suppliers to stop forced installations and later tightened the rules. Self-disconnection, when a prepayment customer simply cannot top up, is much harder to count than a formal shutoff.

Where to look for help: LIHEAP, weatherization and shutoff rules

This section reports what US and UK official pages say about help with energy bills and disconnection rules. It is general information, not legal or financial advice.

Help and what the pages say
HelpWhat the page says
LIHEAP (US, HHS)A federal program that helps with heating and cooling bills, energy-related repairs, weatherization and energy emergencies. Crisis help can include preventing shutoffs, reconnecting service, and repairing or replacing heating equipment. It does not give grants directly to individuals and charges no fee. The national referral line (run by an HHS-funded nonprofit, NCAT) is 1-866-674-6327, weekdays 9am to 7pm ET. The HHS fraud hotline for scams is 1-800-447-8477.
Weatherization (US, DOE)Helps low-income households cut energy costs through efficiency upgrades while ensuring health and safety, at no cost to eligible households, through state and local agencies. DOE says about 32,000 homes a year and average savings of $372 or more a year in a national evaluation. Its apply page gives four steps: determine eligibility, find a local provider, apply, prepare.
Shutoff protections (US)Set by states, generally for regulated utilities. The LIHEAP Clearinghouse summary (HHS-funded, run by NCAT) says 42 states have cold-weather protections, 21 hot-weather, 2 extreme-weather and 44 vulnerable-population protections, often needing a doctor’s note. Municipal utilities, rural electric co-operatives and delivered-fuel providers are generally not covered, and protections do not erase arrears.
Warm Home Discount (England and Wales)Ofgem: £150 for 2026-27 for households in the Core Group (the bill payer or partner receives a qualifying benefit). Scotland has a Core Group plus an application-based Broader Group.
Priority Services Register (UK)Ofgem says suppliers must keep a register with free services for customers in vulnerable situations, and its licence guide says suppliers must not disconnect certain vulnerable customers in winter.
Prepayment meters (UK)Ofgem: suppliers must offer help, such as emergency credit, to people who cannot top up.

On funding, an HHS announcement hosted on the Clearinghouse site (Apr. 17, 2026) says the remaining 10 percent of fiscal year 2026 block grant funds, about $421.5 million, was released. A public-power trade association (not a government source) reports that about $3.6 billion was released on Nov. 28, 2025, and that the administration again proposed eliminating LIHEAP in its fiscal year 2027 request.

What we could not confirm: LIHEAP income limits (no page we could load states them), any official statement on LIHEAP staffing (news reports of layoffs in April 2025 are not confirmed here), a federal shutoff rule, DOE weatherization income thresholds, and Ofgem’s current winter-disconnection wording (its licence guide is from 2019). The Clearinghouse shutoff page shows two update dates, July 2026 and April 2026.

What the evidence does not show

It does not show that every disconnection causes harm to health. Most studies measure associations, not the effect of a single shutoff.

It does not show that moratoria are free. Unpaid bills are usually recovered from other customers or build up as household debt.

It does not measure the problem precisely. Estimates of energy insecurity vary with how questions are asked, and the 2020 survey fell during an unusual year.

And it does not cover most of the world. Almost all the research here is from the United States and the United Kingdom.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

Before

  • In the US, apply for LIHEAP help with heating and cooling bills. It reaches only a fraction of the households that qualify. Official advice see Sources
  • Act on a final notice when it arrives. It usually comes before the power goes. Untested see Sources

Shutoff protections and assistance differ by state and country.

Questions people ask

How many households struggle to pay energy bills?

In 2020, 34 million US households, 27%, reported difficulty paying energy bills or keeping their home at a safe temperature.

What is the heat or eat dilemma?

The trade-off poor households face between paying for heating and buying food. Studies in the US and UK found food spending falls in unusually cold months.

Does energy insecurity affect children’s health?

A study of 9,721 young children found severe energy insecurity was linked to about three times the odds of food insecurity and more reports of poor health.

Did disconnection moratoria help during COVID-19?

One study estimated they cut COVID-19 infections by 4.4% and deaths by 7.4% across US counties.

What help is available with energy bills?

In the US, the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program helps about six million households a year. Many utilities and states also offer payment plans and seasonal protections.

The short version

  • In 2020, 27% of US households, 34 million, had difficulty meeting their energy needs.
  • In both the US and UK, poor households cut food spending during unusually cold weather.
  • Young children in severely energy-insecure homes had about three times the odds of food insecurity.
  • Across US counties, utility disconnection moratoria were estimated to cut COVID-19 deaths by 7.4%.
  • LIHEAP helps about six million households a year; its entire federal staff was laid off in April 2025.

This article summarises published research and public data on energy insecurity. It is not financial or legal advice. If you are struggling with energy bills, contact your utility about payment plans and ask your local community action agency or state LIHEAP office about assistance.

Further reading. Cook and colleagues, ‘A Brief Indicator of Household Energy Security’, Pediatrics, 2008, is the foundational health study. Memmott, Carley, Graff and Konisky, iScience, 2023, is open access and shows what disconnection protections achieved during the pandemic.

Sources

  1. US Energy Information Administration. In 2020, 27% of U.S. households had difficulty meeting their energy needs. Today in Energy, 2022.
  2. US Energy Information Administration. U.S. energy insecure households were billed more for energy than other households. Today in Energy, 2023.
  3. Bhattacharya J, DeLeire T, Haider S, Currie J. Heat or eat? Cold-weather shocks and nutrition in poor American families. American Journal of Public Health, 2003;93(7):1149–1154. doi:10.2105/AJPH.93.7.1149. Working paper version: NBER w9004, 2002.
  4. Hernández D. Understanding ‘energy insecurity’ and why it matters to health. Social Science and Medicine, 2016;167:1–10. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.08.029.
  5. Beatty TKM, Blow L, Crossley TF. Is there a ‘heat-or-eat’ trade-off in the UK? Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A, 2014;177(1):281–294.
  6. Cook JT, Frank DA, Casey PH, and colleagues. A brief indicator of household energy security: associations with food security, child health, and child development in US infants and toddlers. Pediatrics, 2008;122(4):e867–e875. doi:10.1542/peds.2008-0286.
  7. Flaherty ML, Carley S, Konisky DM. Electric utility disconnection policy and vulnerable populations. The Electricity Journal, 2020;33(10):106859.
  8. Jowers K, Timmins C, Bhavsar N, Hu Q, Marshall J. Housing precarity and the COVID-19 pandemic: impacts of utility disconnection and eviction moratoria on infections and deaths across US counties. National Bureau of Economic Research working paper 28394, 2021.
  9. Memmott T, Carley S, Graff M, Konisky DM. Utility disconnection protections and the incidence of energy insecurity in the United States. iScience, 2023;26(3):106244. doi:10.1016/j.isci.2023.106244.
  10. Baker SH, Carley S, Konisky DM. Energy insecurity and the urgent need for utility disconnection protections. Energy Policy, 2021;159:112663.
  11. Utility Dive. Trump guts LIHEAP, threatening $378M in energy assistance already approved by Congress. April 2025.
  12. LeadingAge. LIHEAP funds: HHS releases $3.6 billion in delayed utility assistance funding. December 2025.
  13. HHS ACF. LIHEAP. acf.gov; LIHEAP Clearinghouse (NCAT), NEAR liheapch.ncat.org, FY2026 funds announcement liheapch.ncat.org, Disconnect Policies liheapch.ncat.org.
  14. DOE. Weatherization Assistance Program, modified Oct. 16, 2025 energy.gov; How to apply, modified June 10, 2026 energy.gov.
  15. Ofgem. Warm Home Discount eligibility ofgem.gov.uk; Safety and vulnerable consumer protections licence guide ofgem.gov.uk; Prepayment meter rules ofgem.gov.uk.
  16. American Public Power Association (trade body). Remaining FY 2026 LIHEAP funds disbursed to states publicpower.org.

Similar Posts