Cover tile: 10.2% for not running — hip or knee arthritis in sedentary people versus recreational runners

Running injuries and the arthritis that did not happen

Key takeaways · 10 min read

  • Collegiate cross country runs 4.7 injuries per 1,000 exposures for men and 5.3 for women, below the 6.0 average across 25 sports.
  • Recreational injury rates are far higher, 30 to 79% a year depending on definition, and are almost all overuse injuries of the lower limb.
  • Hip or knee arthritis affected 3.5% of recreational runners, 10.2% of sedentary people and 13.3% of competitive runners.
  • That comparison is cross-sectional, so people who stopped running because of their knees are counted as sedentary.

The common saying is that running wears out your knees. The largest pooled comparison found hip or knee osteoarthritis in 10.2 per cent of sedentary people and 3.5 per cent of recreational runners, so the runners had less of it.

That number does not end the argument, and most of this article is about why. It is still the right place to start, because it inverts the assumption that most reasoning on the subject begins from.

Running does injure people, frequently, and the injuries are almost entirely of one kind. What is unusual is how little of the standard advice for avoiding them survives a randomised trial, including the two rules every beginner is told.

What actually gets injured

Collegiate cross country runs 4.7 injuries per 1,000 athlete-exposures for men and 5.3 for women, against an average of 6.0 across the twenty-five sports in the same surveillance programme. Track is lower still, at 2.7 for men outdoors and 3.5 for women.

Injuries per 1,000 athlete-exposures

NCAA Injury Surveillance Program, 2009-10 to 2013-14. One exposure is one athlete at one practice or one meet.

Wrestling, the highest of 25 sports13.1
American football9.2
All 25 sports6.0
Cross country, women5.3
Cross country, men4.7
Outdoor track, women3.5
Outdoor track, men2.7
Swimming and diving, the lowest1.7

Source: CDC, MMWR 64(48), 2015, NCAA Injury Surveillance Program.

An illustration in dots and straight lines: a single long straight path running to a hard horizon, with one small stone lying on it.
A long way, and one thing in it.

That understates the everyday experience, because a collegiate exposure is short and supervised. Studies of recreational runners have reported annual injury rates from 30 to 79 per cent depending on how injury is defined, and Dutch national figures give about 5.1 injuries per 1,000 hours of running. Novice runners are injured considerably more often than experienced ones.

Severity resembles the rest of college sport. Across all twenty-five sports about a fifth of injuries cost seven days or more, four per cent led to surgery, and roughly half were sprains and strains. Running produces a great many complaints and comparatively few catastrophes.

The injuries themselves are monotonous. They are overuse injuries of the lower limb (the knee, the shin, the Achilles tendon, the plantar fascia, the hip) that arrive gradually rather than in a single moment, with no equivalent of the tackle or the landing. Almost nothing in running injures you suddenly, which is why the advice is all about how quickly you increase things.

The arthritis question

The comparison at the top comes from a meta-analysis of 25 studies covering 125,810 people. Hip or knee osteoarthritis was present in 3.5 per cent of recreational runners (95% CI 3.4 to 3.6), 10.2 per cent of sedentary controls (9.9 to 10.6) and 13.3 per cent of competitive or elite runners (11.6 to 15.2).

Hip or knee osteoarthritis, by how much running

Competitive or elite runners13.3%
Sedentary controls10.2%
Recreational runners3.5%

Source: Alentorn-Geli et al., J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 47(6):373–390, 2017. 25 studies, 125,810 individuals.

An illustration in dots and straight lines: a solid block standing on a hard horizon beside an empty outline of the same block.
The ones who left are not in the picture.

The recreational bar in that figure is well below the sedentary one, and the competitive bar is above it. Whatever running does to joints, it does not do the same thing at 20 miles a week as at 80.

The design cannot carry as much as people want it to. These are cross-sectional prevalence comparisons, so the runners were running at the moment they were counted. Anyone whose knees had already made running unpleasant had left the runner group and joined the sedentary one, and that single mechanism could produce the entire gap without running doing anything protective at all.

A separate meta-analysis of sport and osteoarthritis gives a clearer, more honest version of the finding: across twelve studies, running carried a risk ratio of 0.86 with a confidence interval from 0.53 to 1.41, meaning no significant protection and no significant harm. Soccer, in the same analysis, came out at 1.42. The defensible claim is that recreational running has not been shown to damage knees, which is a good deal more than most people assume, and it falls short of saying running protects them.

Where the risk does not concentrate

Every other sport in this series has a match-to-practice gap. American football carries 39.9 injuries per 1,000 exposures in competition against 5.9 in practice, and basketball 15.0 against 6.7. Running is the sport where that gap nearly closes.

How much a competition concentrates the risk

Competition rate divided by practice rate. Calculated from the published injury and exposure counts.

American football39.9 against 5.96.8x
Soccer, men17.9 against 5.33.4x
Basketball, men15.0 against 6.72.2x
Cross country, women7.8 against 5.11.5x
Cross country, men5.2 against 4.61.1x

Source: CDC, MMWR 64(48), 2015. Competition and practice rates derived from the reported counts.

For men’s cross country the race is barely more dangerous than the training run. That single number reorganises the whole subject: there is no play to legislate away, no equipment to mandate, no moment to coach differently. Whatever is going to prevent a running injury has to work on the ordinary weekday, where all the exposure is.

The counts say the same from the other side. Of the 4,418 injuries recorded in men’s cross country over those five seasons, 3,977 happened in practice, exactly 90 per cent. In women’s cross country it was 4,989 of 5,724, or 87 per cent, against a practice share of 63.8 per cent across all twenty-five sports. Running does almost all of its damage on days nobody is watching.

What has actually been tested

Every new runner is given two pieces of advice: increase weekly distance by no more than ten per cent, and progress gradually. Both have been tested in randomised trials, and both trials came back empty.

Two randomised trials of how to progress

The ten per cent ruleGRONORUN, 2008. 532 novice runners preparing for a four-mile event, randomised to a standard 8-week programme or a graded 13-week one built on the 10% rule. No difference in running-related injuries.
Volume against intensityRun Clever, 2018. 839 recreational runners enrolled, 447 randomised after an eight-week run-in to progress either total volume or intensity over 16 weeks, with GPS-verified training. No difference in injury.

Sources: Buist et al., Am J Sports Med 36(1) (2008); Ramskov et al., BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med 4:e000333 (2018).

An illustration in dots and straight lines: two ladders standing side by side against the same horizontal line, one with closely spaced rungs and one with widely spaced rungs.
Two ways up, arriving together.

Those results do not prove that how you progress is irrelevant. Both trials were in people who were already going to run a fixed amount by a fixed date, which compresses the thing being varied. What they do establish is that the specific, confident, universally repeated version of the advice has no trial support behind it, and has had none for nearly twenty years.

The same holds for most of the rest of the standard list. Static stretching before a run has not been shown to reduce injury, and prescribing a shoe by the shape of a runner’s foot, tested in large military cohorts, did not reduce injury rates either. Running injuries are common, well described and not reliably preventable by anything that has been put in front of a control group.

The rare thing people actually fear

Cardiac arrest during a race is what makes the news, so the denominator helps. Between 2000 and 2010, across 10.9 million runners in United States marathons and half-marathons, there were 59 cardiac arrests.

Cardiac arrest per 100,000 race participants

United States marathons and half-marathons, January 2000 to May 2010. 10.9 million runners, 59 arrests.

Marathon1.01
Men, all races0.90
All runners, all races0.54
Half-marathon0.27
Women, all races0.16

Source: Kim et al., New England Journal of Medicine 366(2):130–140, 2012.

That is one arrest per 185,000 participants overall and one per 99,000 in the marathon specifically. Fifty-one of the fifty-nine were men, the mean age was 42, and cardiovascular disease accounted for most of the arrests, so the race found the condition rather than creating it. Male marathon runners, the highest-risk group, had most of their events in the latter part of the race.

The comparison worth making is with the same population not running at all, where the cardiovascular disease behind most of those arrests continues to exist and is not being exercised. A race is a stress test that a small number of people fail in public.

Why the answer is not to stop

Taken together, the two halves of this article give an unusual shape. The injury rate is high and the preventive advice is weak. The arthritis outcome people fear most, at recreational volumes, goes in the opposite direction from the folklore. The catastrophic outcome is real but sits at roughly one in two hundred thousand.

The evidence supports a posture rather than a technique: expect to be injured at some point, treat that as ordinary instead of a sign you are doing it wrong, and recognise that the things marketed as prevention (the shoe, the stretch, the ten per cent) do not carry the weight they claim. The variable with the clearest evidence behind it is how much you run.

The dose-response in the arthritis figure is the point to keep: recreational volume sits below sedentary, and elite volume sits above it. Almost nobody reading this is near the second.

What the official pages say about running and arthritis

Official pages say little about running and joint arthritis directly. This section sets out what they do say about overuse, mileage and weekly activity. It is general information, not medical advice.

Source and what it says
SourceWhat it says
NIAMS (US government), Osteoarthritis (review date blank)Lists age, overweight, past joint injury or surgery, overuse from repeated movements, malformed joints, family history and female sex as risk factors; exercise reduces pain and stiffness, so start slowly. Running is not mentioned.
Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, 2nd edition (US government), Full guidelines PDF (2018 edition; we read about 100,000 of 134,000 characters)Adults: 150–300 minutes of moderate or 75–150 of vigorous activity a week, plus muscle strengthening 2 or more days. Up to 10,000 steps a day does not appear to worsen osteoarthritis progression, and elite athletes have higher hip and knee osteoarthritis risk, mostly due to injury. Injury risk rises with total activity, with a 40-mile-a-week runner as the example against 10 miles.
NHS (UK government), Knee pain and other running injuries (reviewed Nov. 25, 2022; overdue)Covers runner’s knee, Achilles problems, shin splints and plantar fasciitis, linked to sudden mileage rises, hills and worn shoes. Do a similar run 3–4 times before raising pace or distance; no percentage is given. The page is past its review date.
NHS (UK government), Couch to 5K (no review date shown)Three runs a week for 9 weeks, ending with 30 minutes of continuous running.
CDC (US government), Arthritis: prevention (Feb. 14, 2024)150 minutes a week of moderate activity plus 2 days of strengthening, and says physical activity is safe for people with arthritis. It does not discuss running or what causes osteoarthritis.

We could not confirm any government page that says running does not cause knee or hip arthritis, any government “10 percent rule” (NHS gives only the 3–4 similar runs advice), an NIH page on running and osteoarthritis risk, or an NHS page on avoiding running injuries (it did not load). Several NHS pages we read are past their review dates. Figures were read through automated page fetches, so confirm exact numbers on the live pages.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

Before

  • Choose shoes by comfort rather than arch type. Large military trials that assigned shoes by foot type did not lower injury rates. Measured see Sources
  • Talk to a doctor before training if you have chest pain, unexplained breathlessness, fainting or a family history of sudden cardiac death. Official advice see Sources

If it happens

  • Watch how much you run rather than chasing a technique. Volume is the variable with the clearest evidence behind it. Measured see Sources

What not to do

  • Do not stop running for fear of arthritis. Hip or knee arthritis was 3.5% in recreational runners against 10.2% in sedentary people. Measured see Sources
  • Do not treat the ten per cent rule as proven protection. The trial that tested it found the same injury rate in both arms. Measured see Sources

Questions people ask

So running does not cause arthritis?

The defensible statement is that recreational running has not been shown to cause it and is associated with less of it than sitting still. That association is confounded by who stops running, so the data do not support the confident claim that running wears knees out.

Is the ten per cent rule useless?

It has no randomised support, which does not make it wrong. It is a reasonable default with nothing behind it, and the trial that tested it directly found the same injury rate in both arms.

Should I be fitted for shoes by my gait?

Large military trials that assigned shoes by foot type did not find lower injury rates. Comfort is a better guide than arch classification, and you can assess it yourself.

Do I need a cardiac screen before a marathon?

That is a question for a clinician who knows your history, and the answer depends on symptoms and family history more than on the race. The population rate is about one arrest per 99,000 marathon starters.

Does running injury risk rise with age?

The surveillance data here is collegiate, so it says nothing about masters running. The arthritis meta-analysis adds that the association held in subgroups with more than fifteen years of exposure as well as fewer, which is at least no evidence of a threshold that arrives with time.

What about running on concrete?

Surface hardness has been studied repeatedly and has not emerged as a reliable predictor of injury. The body adjusts leg stiffness to the surface, which is part of why the effect keeps failing to appear.

The short version

  • Collegiate cross country runs 4.7 injuries per 1,000 exposures for men and 5.3 for women, below the 6.0 average across 25 sports.
  • Recreational injury rates are far higher, 30 to 79% a year depending on definition, and are almost all overuse injuries of the lower limb.
  • Hip or knee arthritis affected 3.5% of recreational runners, 10.2% of sedentary people and 13.3% of competitive runners.
  • That comparison is cross-sectional, so people who stopped running because of their knees are counted as sedentary.
  • The ten per cent rule and gradual progression have both been tested in randomised trials and neither reduced injuries.
  • Cardiac arrest ran at 0.54 per 100,000 race participants, 1.01 in marathons and 0.27 in half-marathons.

This describes what published research has reported about a sport, not advice about any individual. Chest pain, unexplained breathlessness, fainting or a family history of sudden cardiac death are reasons to talk to a doctor before training, not reasons to read an article.

Further reading: Alentorn-Geli et al., Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy 47(6):373–390 (2017), for the arthritis meta-analysis. Buist et al., American Journal of Sports Medicine 36(1):33–39 (2008), for the ten per cent rule. Kim et al., New England Journal of Medicine 366(2):130–140 (2012), for the race cardiac arrest data.

Sources

CDC, MMWR 64(48):1330–1336 (2015), NCAA Injury Surveillance Program 2009-10 to 2013-14: cross country and track rates, competition and practice counts, severity distribution.
Alentorn-Geli E, Samuelsson K, Musahl V, et al. The association of recreational and competitive running with hip and knee osteoarthritis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2017;47(6):373–390.
Tran G, Smith TO, Grice A, et al. Does sports participation increase risk of osteoarthritis? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med 2016;50(23):1459–1466.
Buist I, Bredeweg SW, van Mechelen W, et al. No effect of a graded training program on the number of running-related injuries in novice runners. Am J Sports Med 2008;36(1):33–39.
Ramskov D, Rasmussen S, Sørensen HT, et al. Run Clever — no difference in risk of injury when comparing progression in running volume and running intensity in recreational runners. BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med 2018;4:e000333.
Kim JH, Malhotra R, Chiampas G, et al. Cardiac arrest during long-distance running races. N Engl J Med 2012;366(2):130–140.
Verhagen E. Prevention of running-related injuries in novice runners: are we running on empty? Br J Sports Med 2012;46(16):1119–1120 (Dutch national rate of 5.1 injuries per 1,000 hours).

Similar Posts