Cover tile: SPORTS / SOCCER. 3.5x and longer lives.

Soccer injuries: knees, heads, and what the trials found

Key takeaways · 10 min read

  • Football runs 8.0 injuries per 1,000 exposures for men and 8.4 for women, against a 6.0 average across 25 NCAA sports.
  • Football is one of the sports where the women’s rate exceeds the men’s, with ACL tears more than three times higher.
  • Two thirds of concussions do not involve the ball, and the ball accounts for about a third in both collegiate and national data.
  • Matches carry roughly 3.4 times the practice rate, between basketball at 2.2 and American football at 6.8.

A study of 7,676 former Scottish professional footballers, matched against 23,028 people from the general population and followed for a median of eighteen years, found that they died of neurodegenerative disease three and a half times as often. It is the most alarming number in the sport, and it is real.

The same study found they died less often of almost everything else: ischaemic heart disease at a hazard ratio of 0.80 and lung cancer at 0.53. Overall mortality was lower than in the matched controls until about age 70. Both halves came from one dataset, and any honest account of playing football has to carry both.

This article covers what actually gets hurt in football, when, and what the randomised trials found, including on the two interventions people argue over most, the heading rule and the warm-up. The warm-up has a randomised trial behind it, and the heading rule does not.

What actually gets injured, and in whom

The cleanest comparison available is the NCAA injury surveillance data pooled by the CDC across five seasons and twenty-five sports, since every sport in it shares a denominator: injuries per 1,000 athlete-exposures, where an exposure is one athlete in one practice or one game.

Injuries per 1,000 athlete-exposures

NCAA Injury Surveillance Program, 2009-10 to 2013-14. 1,053,370 injuries over 176.7 million exposures.

Wrestling, the highest of 25 sports13.1
American football9.2
Men’s basketball8.5
Women’s soccer8.4
Men’s soccer8.0
Women’s basketball6.5
All 25 sports6.0
Baseball4.7
Swimming and diving, the lowest1.7

Source: CDC, MMWR 64(48), 2015, NCAA Injury Surveillance Program.

Football sits above the twenty-five-sport average and below American football, roughly level with men’s basketball. One line deserves a pause: the women’s rate is higher than the men’s, 8.4 against 8.0. That is not the general pattern, since in basketball the women’s rate is 6.5 against 8.5 for men. Football is one of the sports where the direction reverses.

An illustration in dots and straight lines: two identical doorways on a hard horizon, one of them noticeably narrower than the other.
Two ways through, not the same width.

Mostly one joint explains it. Across ten NCAA seasons, knee injury rates were 38 per cent higher in women’s football than in men’s, and the rate of anterior cruciate ligament tears was more than three times higher: an injury rate ratio of 3.10, with a confidence interval from 2.20 to 4.35. An earlier analysis of the same surveillance system found that the odds of a knee injury requiring surgery were also higher in women, who lost more time when it happened.

Everything else in football is ordinary sports injury. Across all NCAA sports, sprains and strains are about half of the total, roughly a fifth of injuries cost seven days or more, and four per cent lead to surgery. The parts of football that frighten people are not the parts that fill the injury tables.

The ball is a third of it, and the third that has not moved

Concussion is where public argument concentrates, and where the data is most often described backwards. The largest prospective study of the question followed 391 football concussions across thirty universities between 2014 and 2020 and classified each by what the head actually hit.

What the head hit, in 391 collegiate football concussions

The ball, 32.7%Another player’s body, 27.9%Another player’s head, 21.7%Ground or equipment, 17.6%

Source: Jo et al., CARE Consortium, 2024. 30 universities, 2014–2020; 56.8% of the injured players were women.

Two thirds of concussions in football do not involve the ball at all. A separate national dataset of 80,582 youth concussions treated in United States emergency departments between 2013 and 2022 put head-to-ball at 31.0 per cent, close enough to the collegiate figure to reassure about both.

The ball contacts that do cause concussion are also mostly not the ones people picture. An early collegiate surveillance study reported that no concussion in its sample came from a routine, purposeful, successfully executed header; the injuries came from head-to-head collisions in the air and from balls that arrived unexpectedly. The mistimed contest hurts, whatever the technique.

When it concentrates

Football’s risk is concentrated in matches, though less extremely than American football’s. Men’s football runs 17.9 injuries per 1,000 exposures in competition against 5.3 in practice, a ratio of about 3.4, and the women’s figures are 17.2 and 5.6, a ratio of about 3.1.

How much a match concentrates the risk

Competition rate divided by practice rate, same surveillance programme.

American football39.9 against 5.96.8x
Men’s football17.9 against 5.33.4x
Women’s football17.2 against 5.63.1x
Basketball15.0 against 6.72.2x

Source: CDC, MMWR 64(48), 2015. Rates are per 1,000 athlete-exposures.

That shapes what kind of intervention can work. American football could move a large share of its concussions by changing one play, because one play carried them. Football has no such play, and its risk is spread across ninety minutes of contested running, which leaves only interventions the player carries onto the pitch.

Concussion follows the same shape more sharply: in a prospective collegiate cohort, concussions were about two and a half times more likely in competition than in practice, and about one and a half times more likely in women than in men.

What has actually been tested

Structured neuromuscular warm-ups (balance, landing mechanics, knee alignment, hamstring strength, done before training rather than instead of it) are the most tested intervention in the sport. Three randomised trials define what is and is not known.

The one that succeeded on its primary endpoint is the largest: two hundred and thirty Swedish clubs and 4,564 female players aged 12 to 17, randomised by club and followed for one season. Seven players in the intervention group tore an anterior cruciate ligament, against fourteen in the control group, a 64 per cent reduction, rate ratio 0.36, confidence interval 0.15 to 0.85.

Consider what that took: four and a half thousand players, a full season, and a result resting on twenty-one events. Anterior cruciate ligament tears are both severe and rare, which is why smaller trials of the same idea keep coming back inconclusive.

Three randomised warm-up trials

Primary endpoint metWaldén 2012. 4,564 female players aged 12–17, one season. ACL injuries 7 against 14; rate ratio 0.36 (0.15–0.85), a 64% reduction.
Primary endpoint missedSoligard 2008. 1,892 female players aged 13–17. Lower-limb injury, the prespecified outcome: rate ratio 0.71 (0.49–1.03). Overall injury 0.68 (0.48–0.98), overuse 0.47, severe 0.55.
Not significantGilchrist 2008. 1,435 NCAA Division I women. ACL rate 0.199 against 0.340 per 1,000 exposures, a 41% decrease, P = 0.198.

Sources: BMJ 344:e3042 (2012); BMJ 337:a2469 (2008); American Journal of Sports Medicine 36(8) (2008).

An illustration in dots and straight lines: a small object casting a shadow far larger than itself across a flat plane.
A small thing, and the size of what follows it.

The middle trial is the honest one. The Norwegian trial is cited everywhere as proof that warm-ups prevent football injuries, yet its prespecified primary outcome, lower-limb injury, did not reach significance. The secondary outcomes did, including a 53 per cent reduction in overuse injuries and a 45 per cent reduction in severe ones. Those are worth having, but they are not what the trial set out to show.

Read together, the three support a defensible conclusion: a structured warm-up reduces injuries in youth football, the effect on the specific injury everyone cares about is real but was only demonstrated at very large sample size, and the programmes work in proportion to how often they are actually done.

The rule that may not have worked, and the one that did

The United States Soccer Federation’s rule, announced in 2015 under litigation and in force from the following year, banned heading for players aged ten and under and limited players aged 11 to 13 to thirty minutes of heading practice a week. It is the closest thing football has to American football’s kickoff rule, and the evidence that it worked is mixed.

An illustration in dots and straight lines: a sphere resting on a hard horizon with its shadow falling in the wrong direction.
The thing and the account of it, disagreeing.

One analysis compared 7,496 emergency department visits by players aged 10 to 13 in 2013-14 against 2016-17 and found that concussion, as a share of all soccer injuries, had gone up: odds ratio 1.286, confidence interval 1.090 to 1.517. Its authors were careful to say that increased recognition and reporting could explain the whole thing, and that they could not adjust for it.

A longer look at the same national database found the opposite direction: concussion fell from 8.2 per cent of all youth soccer injuries in 2012-15 to 6.1 per cent in 2020-23. A third study of the same decade showed where the fall came from. Head-to-body concussions declined by about 169 a year and head-to-ground by about 155 a year, both significantly, while head-to-ball concussions did not change at all.

That is the uncomfortable sentence. Over the decade in which heading was restricted for young players, the category of concussion the restriction targeted did not move, while the categories it did not target did. The warm-up has a randomised trial, and the heading rule has a natural experiment that points several ways at once.

Why the answer is not to stop

That brings back the Scottish cohort. Neurodegenerative disease was the primary cause of death in 1.7 per cent of former professionals against 0.5 per cent of matched controls, hazard ratio 3.45. Alzheimer’s disease specifically ran at 5.07 and Parkinson’s at 2.15, and dementia medications were dispensed to former players about five times as often.

The same cohort, two directions

7,676 former Scottish professional footballers against 23,028 matched controls, median 18 years of follow-up. Hazard ratios; 1.00 is no difference.

Alzheimer’s disease5.07
Any neurodegenerative disease3.45
Parkinson’s disease2.15
Ischaemic heart disease0.80
Lung cancer0.53

Source: Mackay et al., New England Journal of Medicine 381(19):1801–1808, 2019.

Overall mortality among those players was lower than in the matched population until roughly age 70. By the ordinary measures they were healthier for most of their lives, and then a specific risk arrived late. The authors noted the study was retrospective and said plainly that the findings need confirming in prospective matched cohorts.

The cohort also cannot answer one question: these men played from the 1930s onwards, with different balls, training loads and concussion management. A follow-up of retired professionals cannot tell you whether a player starting today carries the same risk.

The evidence supports something narrower and more useful than either “football causes dementia” or “the scare is overblown.” The specific hazard is head impact accumulated over a professional career. The best-tested way to reduce the injuries that actually fill the tables is a fifteen-minute warm-up done twice a week. And the risk profile of football, a sport played outdoors at an aerobic intensity for decades, is why those same players outlived their neighbours for seventy years first.

What the official pages say about soccer injuries

Heading rules for young players come from soccer bodies rather than governments, and the rules count ages differently. This section keeps those sources apart from the CDC and NHS pages. It is general information, not medical advice.

Source and what it says
SourceWhat it says
CDC HEADS UP (US government), Concussion data (Jan. 27, 2026)Girls soccer ranks second and boys soccer ninth among youth sports for concussion rate. About 1 in 3 concussions among girls and 1 in 4 among boys happen during heading, and heading concussions most often result from collisions between athletes, not from the ball alone. The page does not call for a heading ban.
The Football Association (England, non-government), Youth heading guidance chart (stamp 09/05/2024, ambiguous date)Training only. No heading through under-11; under-12, one session a month with at most 5 headers; under-13, a weekly session with at most 5; under-14, at most 10 headers per session; under-15 and above, one session a week with at most 10 headers. Match rules are unchanged.
US Soccer (non-government), Recognize to Recover announcement (Dec. 2, 2015, stale)Prohibits heading for ages 10 and under and limits it to practice for ages 11 to 13. Nothing is said about 14 and over, and we could not fetch a current rules page.
UK Government, Response to the DCMS committee on concussion in sport (Dec. 10, 2021)Notes the FA’s training heading guidance from the 2021–22 season and sets no youth heading rules itself. It cites a study in which former professional footballers were about 3.5 times more likely to die of dementia, with no cause established.
F-MARC, the FIFA 11+ programme site (non-government), FIFA 11+ (undated, latest reference 2016)Teams doing the programme at least twice a week had 37% fewer training injuries, 29% fewer match injuries and almost 50% fewer severe injuries. It has 3 parts and 15 exercises and is aimed at amateur players aged 14 and over.
NHS (UK government), ACL surgery: why it is done (reviewed July 17, 2025)ACL injury is usually a sports injury. Surgery is usually considered if physiotherapy has not helped, the person plans to keep doing a lot of sport, the knee often gives way or other parts of the knee are damaged. No statistics given.
Our comparisonUS Soccer counts “10 and under” and “11 to 13”; the FA counts under-11 and under-12. The cut-offs are not interchangeable.

We could not confirm a current US Soccer heading page, the full FA guidance document, a FIFA-run page for FIFA 11+ (only the F-MARC site), a UK government rule on children’s heading, or the NHS ACL condition page (it did not load). Figures were read through automated page fetches, so confirm exact numbers on the live pages.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

Before

  • Do an injury-prevention warm-up, fifteen minutes twice a week, and do it consistently. The largest trial cut ACL injuries by 64%. Measured see Sources
  • Make it a priority for female players. ACL tears run more than three times higher, and the trials with the largest reductions were in this group. Measured see Sources

Afterwards

  • After a suspected concussion, leave the pitch and be assessed. Return-to-play decisions belong to a clinician. Official advice see Sources

What not to do

  • Do not buy padded headgear to prevent concussion. A trial of 2,766 high school players found no difference. Measured see Sources
  • Do not do the warm-up only occasionally. Programmes done occasionally produced almost nothing. Measured see Sources

Questions people ask

Should children be allowed to head the ball?

The restrictions are in force in several countries and are reasonable given what is unknown. The data does not yet show that they reduce concussion, since the mechanism they target is the one category that did not decline over the decade they were introduced. That is a reason to keep measuring and no reason to drop them.

Why do female players tear their ACLs so much more often?

The measured gap is more than threefold in collegiate football, and the explanation is not settled: landing mechanics, hip and knee geometry, neuromuscular control and hormonal cycle have all been studied. The warm-up trials showing the largest reductions were run in exactly this population.

Does a headgear or a padded band help?

Not on the evidence available. A cluster randomised trial of 2,766 high school players over 3,050 participant-years found no difference in concussion rate, with a hazard ratio of 0.86 (0.54 to 1.36) in females and 2.00 (0.63 to 6.43) in males, and no difference in days lost, 13.5 against 13.0.

Is the warm-up worth it for an adult recreational player?

The randomised evidence is in adolescents, so extrapolating upward is a judgement rather than a finding. The mechanism, better landing and deceleration control, does not obviously stop applying with age, and the intervention costs fifteen minutes.

What actually matters most if I only change one thing?

Do the warm-up, and do it consistently. Across this literature the programmes done as prescribed produced the large effects and those done occasionally produced almost nothing. Adherence is the variable that moves, more than programme choice.

The short version

  • Football runs 8.0 injuries per 1,000 exposures for men and 8.4 for women, against a 6.0 average across 25 NCAA sports.
  • Football is one of the sports where the women’s rate exceeds the men’s, with ACL tears more than three times higher.
  • Two thirds of concussions do not involve the ball, and the ball accounts for about a third in both collegiate and national data.
  • Matches carry roughly 3.4 times the practice rate, between basketball at 2.2 and American football at 6.8.
  • The largest warm-up trial cut ACL injuries 64% (rate ratio 0.36), but the most-cited one missed its own primary endpoint.
  • Former professionals died of neurodegenerative disease 3.45 times as often, but died less often of heart disease and lung cancer, with lower overall mortality until about 70.

This describes what published research has reported about a sport, not advice about any individual. Head injury is a clinical matter: a suspected concussion means leaving the pitch and being assessed, and return-to-play decisions belong to a clinician, not to an article or a coach.

Further reading: Mackay et al., New England Journal of Medicine 381(19):1801–1808 (2019), for the Scottish cohort. Waldén et al., BMJ 344:e3042 (2012), for the knee-control trial. Soligard et al., BMJ 337:a2469 (2008), for the trial that missed its primary endpoint and is quoted as though it did not.

Sources

CDC, MMWR 64(48):1330–1336 (2015), NCAA Injury Surveillance Program 2009-10 to 2013-14: sport-by-sport rates per 1,000 athlete-exposures, competition and practice counts, severity distribution.
Mackay DF, Russell ER, Stewart K, MacLean JA, Pell JP, Stewart W. Neurodegenerative disease mortality among former professional soccer players. N Engl J Med 2019;381(19):1801–1808.
Waldén M, Atroshi I, Magnusson H, Wagner P, Hägglund M. Prevention of acute knee injuries in adolescent female football players: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2012;344:e3042.
Soligard T, Myklebust G, Steffen K, et al. Comprehensive warm-up programme to prevent injuries in young female footballers: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2008;337:a2469.
Gilchrist J, Mandelbaum BR, Melancon H, et al. A randomized controlled trial to prevent non-contact anterior cruciate ligament injury in female collegiate soccer players. Am J Sports Med 2008;36(8):1476–1483.
Jo J, Boltz AJ, Williams KL, et al. Mechanisms of injury leading to concussions in collegiate soccer players: a CARE Consortium study. Am J Sports Med 2024 (30 universities, 391 concussions, 2014–2020).
Chun AG, Snyder EM, Obana KK, et al. The 10-year decreasing trend of youth soccer head injuries and concussions presenting to U.S. emergency departments. Phys Sportsmed 2024.
Sullivan G, Lin E, Hoffer AJ, et al. Pediatric concussion injuries in soccer: emergency department trends in the United States from 2012 to 2023. Orthop J Sports Med 2024;12(12).
Lalji R, Snider H, Chow N, Howitt S. The 2015 U.S. Soccer Federation header ban and its effect on emergency room concussion rates in soccer players aged 10–13 (NEISS, 7,496 attendances).
McGuine TA, Post EG, Pfaller AY, et al. Does soccer headgear reduce the incidence of sport-related concussion? A cluster, randomised controlled trial of adolescent athletes. Br J Sports Med 2020;54(7):408–413.
Chandran A, Rao N, Boltz AJ, et al. Knee and ACL injury rates in NCAA soccer players: an epidemiological study of 10 consecutive seasons. Science and Medicine in Football 2025.

Similar Posts