Cover: 10% came after. Resisting a robbery, what the evidence shows.
|

Resisting a Robbery: What the Evidence Shows

Key takeaways · 11 min read

  • Victim surveys carry most of this research, because fewer than half of violent crimes in the US are reported to the police.
  • Early studies suggested that resisting a robbery protected property while raising the risk of injury.
  • In a study of 27,595 crimes, injury followed resistance in only 10% of the cases where both occurred.
  • Across studies, non-physical resistance such as running or calling for help has the lowest injury rates.

Ask most police forces, travel guides or self-defence instructors what to do in a street robbery and the answer is the same: hand it over. Property can be replaced; you cannot.

For most people in most robberies that is probably right. It is not quite what the research says, though. The best American data suggest that people who resist are, on average, less likely to lose their property and no more likely to be hurt, and the reasons are subtler than either side of the argument usually admits.

This article covers what decades of victimisation surveys show about resisting robbery and assault, why the early studies seemed to point the other way, and where the evidence is weakest. One number changed the debate: in a 2004 study of 27,595 crimes, the injury came after the resistance in only 10% of cases where a victim both resisted and was injured.

How common is it?

The National Crime Victimization Survey has been the main source of American data on robbery and assault since 1973. The Bureau of Justice Statistics runs it with the Census Bureau, interviewing a large sample of households about crimes they experienced, whether or not they told the police.

In 2024, 1.45% of Americans aged 12 or older experienced at least one violent victimisation, about the same as the year before. The overall rate was 23.3 violent victimisations per 1,000 people, but only 11.2 per 1,000 were reported to the police. Fewer than half of these crimes ever appear in police statistics.

That is why almost all research on how victims respond comes from the survey rather than from police records. The survey asks a simple question: did you do anything, while the incident was going on, to protect yourself or your property? If the answer is yes, it asks what, and whether it happened before or after any injury.

The survey has one limitation from the start: it only interviews survivors. People killed in robberies cannot be asked what they did. Such killings are rare compared with robberies, but the gap means the survey can say little about the rarest and worst outcomes.

Violent crime in the United States, 2024

People aged 12 or older, National Crime Victimization Survey.

23.3violent victimisations per 1,000 people
11.2per 1,000 reported to the police

Bureau of Justice Statistics, Criminal Victimization, 2024, September 2025.

A pointillist illustration: an empty pedestrian underpass at night, its tiled walls lit by a line of lamps, one lamp glowing amber at the far end.
An underpass at night. Most research on robbery comes from what survivors say they did.

What the early studies found

Research on victim resistance began in earnest in the 1980s, using earlier versions of the same survey. The findings were mixed, and they shaped the advice that is still given today.

Richard Block and Wesley Skogan, in 1986, looked at encounters between strangers that could have become robberies. Forceful resistance, such as fighting back, was linked to robbers succeeding less often, but robbery victims who resisted forcefully were more likely to be attacked. Non-forceful resistance, such as running away or shouting, was linked to both fewer completed robberies and fewer attacks.

Eduard Ziegenhagen and Dolores Brosnan analysed 3,679 robberies in 13 cities. Resistance was not often associated with serious injury but was linked to preventing the robbery, and they argued that advice to submit could be harmful.

Gary Kleck and Miriam DeLone used more than 4,500 robberies from 1979 to 1985. Almost any kind of self-protection reduced the chance that the robber got away with the property. Two kinds of resistance seemed to increase injury: unarmed physical force, and trying to attract attention or scare the robber off.

This first generation of studies suggested that resisting helped protect property but might increase the chance of being hurt, especially if it involved physical force. The standard advice rests on that trade-off.

The sequence problem

The early studies had a weakness that was hard to see in the data: they recorded whether a victim resisted and whether a victim was injured, but not always which came first.

Order matters. If a robber hits someone and the victim then fights back, the injury did not result from the resistance. In a simple analysis, though, that victim counts as someone who resisted and was injured, and resistance looks dangerous.

A pointillist illustration: a bus shelter beside a lamppost on a dark street corner, the lamp glowing amber above an empty pavement.
A bus shelter at night. In most incidents where a victim resisted and was hurt, the injury came first.

Jongyeon Tark and Gary Kleck addressed this directly. In a 2004 paper in Criminology, they analysed 27,595 personal contact crimes recorded in the survey from 1992 to 2001, covering robberies, assaults and sexual assaults, and 16 different kinds of self-protective action.

Self-protection in general, both forceful and non-forceful, reduced the likelihood of property loss and of injury compared with doing nothing. In crimes where the victim both resisted and was injured, the injury followed the resistance in only 10% of cases; in the other 90%, the victim was hurt first or at the same time. Much of the apparent link between resistance and injury, the authors concluded, came from getting the order of events backwards.

When a victim resisted and was hurt, which came first?

Personal contact crimes where both self-protection and injury occurred, 1992 to 2001.

Injury came first or at the same time~90%
Injury came after the resistance10%

Tark J, Kleck G, Criminology, 2004. 27,595 incidents from the National Crime Victimization Survey.

Not all resistance is the same

Studies that came later split self-protection into types and found differences by type and by offender.

Ronet Bachman and colleagues studied assaults against women and paid close attention to the sequence of events. Injury was least likely when women used non-physical strategies such as arguing or reasoning with the offender, whatever the kind of offender. In assaults by intimate partners, however, women who physically resisted were more likely to be injured.

In a 2022 study of assault victims aged 65 and over, Bachman found something similar: older victims who used only verbal or passive resistance were about 57% less likely to be injured than those who did nothing or who resisted physically.

The pattern across studies is fairly consistent. Running away, calling for help, and talking or arguing are generally associated with lower injury rates, while physical resistance without a weapon has the least consistent record and in some settings goes with more injury.

What different studies found about resisting

Studies of robbery and assault using US victimisation surveys.

StudyFocusMain finding
Block and Skogan, 1986Stranger robberyNon-forceful resistance linked to fewer attacks
Kleck and DeLone, 1993Robbery, 1979–85Most resistance cut property loss
Bachman and colleagues, 2002Assaults on womenVerbal strategies had the lowest injury
Tark and Kleck, 200427,595 crimesInjury followed resistance in 10% of cases
Bachman, 2022Victims aged 65+Verbal or passive resistance: 57% less injury

Violence and Victims; Journal of Quantitative Criminology; Journal of Family Violence; Criminology.

What robbers say

Victim surveys see robbery from one side. A few studies have asked robbers themselves.

Richard Wright and Scott Decker wrote the best-known study, interviewing 86 active armed robbers in St Louis in the 1990s for their book Armed Robbers in Action. The robbers described the gun as a tool for getting quick compliance, and said they did not want to use it. They aimed to create enough fear that the victim would hand over money without delay.

They also described using violence to re-establish control when victims hesitated, argued or fought back. From the robber’s side, resistance was a problem to be solved, sometimes with force.

That helps explain why the survey averages hide so much variation. A robber who is nervous, armed and in a hurry may respond to resistance very differently from one who is opportunistic and ready to run, and the victim rarely knows which kind they are facing.

What about guns?

Some of the studies above found resistance with a gun among the most effective ways to prevent property loss and injury. The numbers deserve care, since this is the most politically charged part of the literature.

Defensive gun use is rare in the survey. David Hemenway and Sara Solnick, in Preventive Medicine in 2015, examined more than 14,000 incidents from 2007 to 2011 where the victim was present, and a gun was used in self-defence in 127 of them, or 0.9%. After any protective action, 4.2% of victims were injured; after defensive gun use, 4.1%. In robberies and other crimes aimed at property, 55.9% of victims who took some protective action lost property, compared with 38.5% of those who used a gun and 34.9% of those who used another weapon.

A 2024 analysis in the American Journal of Public Health by David McDowall and colleagues estimated that American crime victims reported using a gun defensively in about 61,000 to 65,000 incidents a year, a level that has been nearly constant since the late 1980s. That is small compared with the millions of crimes the survey records each year.

Supporters and critics of gun ownership read these figures differently, and other surveys produce far higher estimates of defensive gun use. In the national victimisation survey, armed self-defence is uncommon and not clearly more protective against injury than other kinds of action.

Property lost after different protective actions

Crimes aimed at property where the victim was present, 2007 to 2011.

Any protective action55.9%
Used a gun38.5%
Used another weapon34.9%

Hemenway D, Solnick SJ, Preventive Medicine, 2015. Injury after any protective action was 4.2%, after gun use 4.1%.

At work: when the robbery is of a shop

Commercial robberies differ because the property belongs to an employer and staff are often trained not to resist. The evidence supports that training.

Jennifer Jones, Carri Casteel and Corinne Peek-Asa studied police reports of commercial robberies in a large US city from 2008 to 2012. Employees resisted in nearly half of the robberies, and active resistance was associated with a 49% higher prevalence of employee injury. Robberies where goods were taken were more likely to involve resistance and injury; those where only cash was taken were less likely to involve injury.

The calculation is clearer here than on the street. The employee has little personal stake in the money, the robber may be more determined, and a shop has cameras and records that help police afterwards. Training staff not to resist is one of the few robbery-prevention measures with consistent support.

Employee resistance in commercial robberies

Police reports, large US metropolitan city, 2008 to 2012.

~50%of commercial robberies involved employee resistance
1.49xinjury prevalence when employees actively resisted

Jones J, Casteel C, Peek-Asa C, Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 2015.

A pointillist illustration: a shop counter at night with a cash register, its small display glowing amber, shelves dim behind it.
A shop counter after closing. For staff, not resisting has the most consistent support.

Why the evidence is hard to act on

Even the best studies here are observational. Victims were not randomly assigned to resist or comply, and people who resist may differ from those who do not in size, fitness, confidence and circumstances.

Situation matters as well. A victim facing a single unarmed teenager in daylight near other people is in a very different position from one facing several armed adults in an empty car park, and averages across thousands of incidents cannot tell any one person what to do in a particular moment.

The survey also cannot see the worst outcomes. People killed during robberies are missing from victimisation data, so if resistance occasionally provokes lethal violence, the survey would not show it.

Most safety guidance therefore still leans towards compliance, especially when a weapon is present, while noting that running away, shouting and calling for help are generally reasonable if they are possible.

What the evidence does not show

Resisting is not shown to be always safer: the averages hide large differences between situations, and the survey excludes those who were killed.

Fighting back unarmed gets no support either. That form of resistance has the least consistent record and in some settings is linked to more injury.

The gun debate stays open. Defensive gun use is rare in the national survey, and its estimated effect on injury is similar to other protective actions.

Nor is the standard advice wrong. Handing over property remains a reasonable default, especially when an offender is armed.

If it happens: what police and safety agencies advise

The research above asks whether resisting makes a robbery more dangerous. This section covers the practical side: what published advice says to do, and a few official counts for scale. Every piece of advice below comes from a university, state or city agency; the FBI page we read gave none.

Step 1: stay calm and do not resist. The University of Southern California Department of Public Safety (page modified 20 April 2026), the Missouri State Highway Patrol (brochure dated August 2021, aimed at bank and business staff) and a City of Houston brochure for businesses agree: cooperate, and hand over only what is demanded.

Step 2: move slowly and say so. Announce any movement before you make it, such as reaching into a pocket, and avoid sudden moves and arguing. The Missouri patrol says to assume the robber is armed and notes that most holdups last about 1.5 to 3 minutes.

Step 3: note what you can. The robber’s appearance, weapon, vehicle and direction of travel, and anything touched.

Step 4: get safe, then call 911. Keep witnesses at the scene or take their contact details if they leave, and do not touch anything. The Missouri patrol adds that alarms should be triggered only when it is safe.

The scale. The Bureau of Justice Statistics survey estimates 642,150 robbery victimizations in 2024, a rate of 2.2 per 1,000 people aged 12 or older, against 731,620 (2.6 per 1,000) in 2023. The FBI’s 2025 summary puts the estimated robbery rate at 49.4 per 100,000 against 61.0 in 2024, the lowest in 20 years, with the estimated count down 18.5%. Among 149,332 robbery offenses from agencies reporting through NIBRS, 45,337 involved a firearm and 13,630 a knife or cutting instrument; offenses can list several weapons, so these do not add up to the total.

What we could not confirm. We found no federal page telling civilians what to do during a robbery, and no official data showing that complying is statistically safer than resisting; the post’s research sections cover that evidence. BJS gives different shares of robberies reported to police (from about 49% to about 74%) depending on which survey version is used, so we have not printed a single figure. We found no robbery-specific injury share from BJS.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

If it happens

  • If a weapon is present, comply. Most safety guidance leans that way, and robbers described using force when victims argued or fought back. Official advice see Sources
  • Running away, shouting and calling for help are generally reasonable if they are possible. Official advice see Sources
  • At work, do not resist. Active resistance by shop staff was linked to 49% more injuries. Measured see Sources

The evidence is observational. Averages cannot tell any one person what to do in a particular moment.

Questions people ask

Should you resist a robbery?

There is no single right answer. Survey data suggest that resisting reduces property loss and does not, on average, increase injury. They exclude people who were killed, however, and the safest choice depends on the situation.

Does fighting back make injury more likely?

Early studies suggested so. A 2004 study found that when victims resisted and were injured, the injury came after the resistance in only 10% of cases.

What kind of resistance is safest?

Non-physical strategies such as running away, calling for help, or talking to the offender are generally associated with the lowest injury rates.

How common is defensive gun use?

In the national victimisation survey, a gun was used in self-defence in about 0.9% of incidents where the victim was present.

What should shop staff do?

Research on commercial robberies found that active resistance by employees was linked to 49% more injuries. Training staff not to resist has consistent support.

The short version

  • Victim surveys carry most of this research, because fewer than half of violent crimes in the US are reported to the police.
  • Early studies suggested that resisting a robbery protected property while raising the risk of injury.
  • In a study of 27,595 crimes, injury followed resistance in only 10% of the cases where both occurred.
  • Across studies, non-physical resistance such as running or calling for help has the lowest injury rates.
  • For shop staff, active resistance was linked to 49% more injuries, and non-resistance training has consistent support.

This article summarises published research on victim resistance. It is not safety or legal advice. In an emergency, call your local emergency number. Local police and victim support services can give guidance suited to where you live.

Further reading. Tark and Kleck, ‘Resisting Crime: The Effects of Victim Action on the Outcomes of Crimes’, Criminology, 2004, is the most thorough study of the sequence problem. Hemenway and Solnick, Preventive Medicine, 2015, gives the clearest picture of how rare armed self-defence is in survey data.

Sources

  1. Bureau of Justice Statistics. Criminal Victimization, 2024. September 2025.
  2. Block R, Skogan WG. Resistance and nonfatal outcomes in stranger-to-stranger predatory crime. Violence and Victims, 1986;1(4):241–253.
  3. Ziegenhagen EA, Brosnan D. Victim responses to robbery and crime control policy. Criminology, 1985;23(4):675–695.
  4. Kleck G, DeLone MA. Victim resistance and offender weapon effects in robbery. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 1993;9(1):55–81.
  5. Tark J, Kleck G. Resisting crime: the effects of victim action on the outcomes of crimes. Criminology, 2004;42(4):861–910. doi:10.1111/j.1745-9125.2004.tb00539.x.
  6. Bachman R, Saltzman LE, Thompson MP, Carmody DC. Disentangling the effects of self-protective behaviors on the risk of injury in assaults against women. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 2002;18(2):135–157.
  7. Bachman R. When older assault victims fight back: investigating the effects of self-protective behaviors on the probability of injury. 2022.
  8. Wright RT, Decker SH. Armed Robbers in Action: Stickups and Street Culture. Northeastern University Press, 1997.
  9. Hemenway D, Solnick SJ. The epidemiology of self-defense gun use: evidence from the National Crime Victimization Surveys 2007–2011. Preventive Medicine, 2015;79:22–27. doi:10.1016/j.ypmed.2015.03.029.
  10. McDowall D, Wiersema B, Loftin C, McCleary R. Levels and changes in defensive firearm use by US crime victims, 1987–2021. American Journal of Public Health, 2024;114(12):1384–1387. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2024.307838.
  11. Jones J, Casteel C, Peek-Asa C. Employee resistance and injury during commercial robberies. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 2015;57(5):531–536. doi:10.1097/JOM.0000000000000396.
  12. University of Southern California Department of Public Safety. “Robbery” safety tips (modified 20 April 2026).
  13. Missouri State Highway Patrol. Robbery brochure SHP-555D (August 2021).
  14. City of Houston. Robbery brochure for businesses (undated).
  15. Bureau of Justice Statistics. “Criminal Victimization, 2024” (NCJ 310547, September 2025).
  16. FBI Uniform Crime Reporting. Summary of Reported Crimes in the Nation, 2025 (released August 2026).

Similar Posts