Dark title card reading 43 per cent and nothing at all, over a note about hip fractures in deficient nursing-home women against three trials in replete adults.

Vitamin D: Food Sources, Sunlight, and What the Trials Found

Key takeaways · 11 min read

  • The skin makes it from UVB at 290–320 nm. Its established role is calcium absorption and bone mineralisation.
  • Per tablespoon, cod liver oil gives 34.0 µg, canned sockeye 3.15 and cooked trout 2.85. No other food comes close; cod flesh has 278 times less than the oil.
  • Food supplies about a third of the RDA in the average US diet, yet only 5 per cent of people are deficient. Skin makes up the difference, and no food table records it.
  • Deficiency causes rickets in children and osteomalacia in adults. Fortification from the 1930s made rickets rare, though it is returning in places.

Vitamin D sits awkwardly in a series about food, because its main supply is not eaten. Given a raw material and some light, the body makes it for itself, and no other nutrient here does that. Strictly it is a hormone precursor rather than a vitamin, and it is classed as one because enough of us live indoors that we have to be fed it.

Three things follow. The food table is accurate but nearly irrelevant, the deficiency figures do not match the intake figures, and the large supplement trials came back mostly empty while one much smaller, older trial found a 43 per cent cut in hip fracture. Both results are real, and the reason they differ is the most useful point on this page.

This is the second vitamin entry in this appendix: what the nutrient does, which foods carry it per measured spoonful, what running short does, and what the reference numbers are.

What it does

On uncovered skin, ultraviolet B at roughly 290 to 320 nanometres converts 7-dehydrocholesterol into previtamin D3. The liver turns that into 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25(OH)D), the circulating form and the one a blood test measures. The kidney then converts a fraction of it into 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, the active hormone.

Its established job is calcium handling: it governs how much calcium and phosphate the gut absorbs and how the skeleton mineralises. Without enough, dietary calcium is largely wasted and the mineral passes through. That is the whole of the settled biology; most other effects attributed to vitamin D are associations still waiting for a trial.

Abstract composition of dots and ruled lines: a dense field falling from the top of the frame, with a small tightly packed square at the foot.
Most of it arrives from somewhere the food table cannot see.

The three foods that carry the most per spoonful

Using the US Department of Agriculture’s composition values and ranking by what fits on a level tablespoon, vitamin D gives the steepest drop in this series.

Vitamin D per level tablespoon

USDA SR Legacy values for vitamin D (D2 + D3) per 100 g, converted to one level tablespoon: 15 g for solids, 13.6 g for oil. Share is of the 15 µg (600 IU) adult RDA.

Food (USDA FDC ID)Per 100 gPer tablespoonShare of RDA
Cod liver oil (173577)250 µg34.0 µg227%
Salmon, sockeye, canned, drained (173693)21.0 µg3.15 µg21%
Trout, rainbow, farmed, cooked (173718)19.0 µg2.85 µg19%
Salmon, sockeye, cooked (173692)16.7 µg2.51 µg17%
Salmon, sockeye, raw (173691)14.1 µg2.12 µg14%
Herring, Atlantic, cooked (175117)5.4 µg0.81 µg5%
Cod, Atlantic, raw (171955)0.9 µg0.14 µg1%

Source: USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy. Tablespoon figures are conversions at the stated weights. 1 µg = 40 IU.

Cod liver oil carries eleven times what the next food does, and after it the list drops sharply: no ordinary food gives you a quarter of a day on a spoon. Compare the last row with the first. Cod flesh holds 0.9 µg per 100 g, while the oil pressed from the same fish’s liver holds 250, some two hundred and eighty times as much. The vitamin D is in the liver, not the flesh.

The arithmetic checks against an independent table: the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements lists cod liver oil at 34.0 µg per tablespoon, cooked trout at 16.2 per three ounces and cooked sockeye at 14.2, and converting the USDA values to the same weights gives 34.0, 16.2 and 14.2.

The source that is not in the table

In 2015–2016 the average American adult got 5.1 µg a day from food if male and 4.2 if female, about a third of the RDA, fortified milk and cereal included. If food were the whole story, deficiency would be near-universal. It was not: in the 2011–2014 national survey, 5 per cent of Americans were below the deficiency threshold of 30 nmol/L and 18 per cent sat in the inadequate band from 30 to 49. Three quarters were fine on a third of the recommended intake. The missing input is skin, which appears in no food table.

That is why nobody can say how many minutes of sun you need. The ODS lists the variables (season, time of day, length of day, cloud cover, smog, melanin and sunscreen) and declines to give a number. Glass matters too: UVB does not pass through it, so a sunny room produces nothing. Sunscreen at SPF 8 or above blocks the wavelengths involved, though the same fact sheet notes that in practice people do not apply enough or reapply it.

The spread underneath follows sunlight and skin: 17.5 per cent of non-Hispanic Black Americans were below the deficiency threshold, against 7.6 per cent of non-Hispanic Asian, 5.9 of Hispanic and 2.1 of non-Hispanic white Americans. Age ran opposite to expectation. The peak was adults aged 20 to 39, at 7.6 per cent, against 2.9 for the over-60s.

What running short does

Deficiency disease is a failure of mineralisation: rickets in children, where bone fails to harden and deforms, and osteomalacia in adults, where remodelled bone is laid down incompletely. Both are caused by shortage and both respond to correcting it. Fortifying milk and other staples from the 1930s, along with cod liver oil, made rickets rare in the United States, one of the clearest public health wins on record. It has been returning in places, largely among immigrant populations.

The groups who run short are predictable. Breastfed infants are one, since breast milk carries little and only 20.5 per cent receive the recommended supplement. Others are anyone who cannot absorb fat (liver disease, cystic fibrosis, coeliac disease, Crohn’s, ulcerative colitis), people rarely outdoors or who cover their skin, people with darker skin at high latitudes, and people with a BMI of 30 or above, or after gastric bypass, who consistently show lower serum levels.

The trials, and why they disagree

Observational data linking low levels to almost everything made vitamin D the most-tested supplement in medicine from about 2005. Three very large randomised trials then reported, and came back close to flat.

Fracture risk in the large supplementation trials

Hazard ratios. Below 1.00 favours supplementation; bars show distance from 1.00 either way, full bar = 25 per cent.

VITAL · 25,871 · 2,000 IU/day · baseline 30.2 ng/mL0.98
D-Health · 20,326 · 60,000 IU/month · 5.1 years0.94
ViDA · 5,108 · 100,000 IU/month · baseline 25.2 ng/mL1.19
Chapuy · 3,270 nursing-home women · baseline 16 ng/mL · with calcium0.57

Sources: Dawson-Hughes, B., Metabolism Open, 2024, 100300, reviewing LeBoff et al. 2022 (VITAL), Waterhouse et al. 2023 (D-Health), Khaw et al. 2017 (ViDA) and Chapuy et al., NEJM 327, 1992. The Chapuy figure is hip fracture; the others are total or non-vertebral fracture.

VITAL gave 2,000 IU a day to 25,871 adults for 5.3 years: total fracture hazard ratio 0.98 (0.89–1.08), hip fracture 1.01 (0.70–1.47), odds of two or more falls 0.97. D-Health, 20,326 people on 60,000 IU monthly, gave 0.94 for fracture and 1.11 for hip. ViDA, 5,108 people on 100,000 IU monthly, gave 1.19 for non-vertebral fracture — pointing the wrong way, with an interval covering both real harm and real benefit.

Abstract composition: two ruled cells of equal size, the left one densely filled with dots and the right one nearly empty, with an identical band of dots laid across both.
The same amount added to a full room and an empty one.

The other trial dates from 1992. Chapuy and colleagues gave 3,270 French nursing-home women, mean age 84.6, 800 IU of vitamin D3 with 1.2 grams of calcium for eighteen months. Hip fractures fell by 43 per cent and other non-vertebral fractures by 32, and the result has not been overturned.

Who was enrolled explains the difference, and the dose and trial quality do not. VITAL’s participants began at a mean 25(OH)D of 30.2 ng/mL, above every sufficiency threshold anyone proposes; Chapuy’s began at 16, below the deficiency line, on a calcium intake of 511 mg a day that is itself inadequate. One trial treated a deficiency. The other added a nutrient to people who already had enough.

A supplement treats a shortage, and testing it in people without one answers a different question. VITAL did look at the deficient: even in the subgroup starting below 12 ng/mL falls did not move, though that subgroup was small, as such groups usually are.

The other end of the range

Above the sufficiency line, vitamin D does not simply stop helping. Its relationship with falls appears U-shaped, with the low point somewhere around 20 to 40 ng/mL, and above 60 ng/mL the odds of two or more falls have been reported at 1.99 (1.2–3.3). In D-Health, the subgroup with a BMI below 25, whose levels rise most on a given dose, had a fall odds ratio of 1.25 (1.09–1.43). STURDY compared 1,000 IU a day against 200 and recorded more serious falls on the higher dose; a single annual dose of 500,000 IU raised falls by 15 per cent and fractures by 26.

True toxicity sits much higher and is unambiguous: hypercalcaemia, typically above 375 nmol/L (150 ng/mL), producing nausea, muscle weakness, confusion, thirst and kidney stones, and in extreme cases renal failure, calcification of soft tissue including heart valves, and death. It is essentially always caused by supplements. Sunlight does not cause it, and neither does food.

Abstract composition: dots dense at the left and right edges of the frame and thin through the middle, divided by two vertical ruled lines.
Risk that falls, flattens, and then turns back up.

The numbers, and where they came from

The RDA is 15 µg (600 IU) a day from age 1 to 70 and 20 µg (800 IU) above 70, with an adequate intake of 10 µg (400 IU) for infants; the upper level is 100 µg (4,000 IU) from age 9 up. The recommendation is deliberately written for someone who gets no sun at all, which is part of why measured intakes sit so far below it without producing the deficiency you would predict.

The band, in micrograms a day

US Dietary Reference Intakes. Full bar = the adult upper level of 100 µg (4,000 IU).

Average intake from food, adult men5.1
RDA, ages 1 to 7015
RDA, over 7020
One tablespoon of cod liver oil34
Upper level, ages 9 and above100

Sources: NIH Office of Dietary Supplements; USDA FoodData Central (173577).

Serum 25(OH)D and what the committees say about it

The thresholds the Institute of Medicine set, in the two units in common use.

BELOW 30 nmol/L · 12 ng/mLDeficiency. Rickets in children, osteomalacia in adults.
30 TO 49 · 12 TO 19.6Generally considered inadequate for bone and overall health.
50 AND ABOVE · 20 AND ABOVEGenerally considered adequate for most people. This is the sufficiency line.
ABOVE 125 · ABOVE 50Linked to potential adverse effects, particularly above 150 nmol/L (60 ng/mL).

Source: NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, after the Institute of Medicine Food and Nutrition Board, 2011.

That 20 ng/mL line is not universally accepted. The Endocrine Society declines to identify concentrations for sufficiency, insufficiency and deficiency at all, and does not recommend routine 25(OH)D testing in healthy people, on the grounds that the evidence does not support drawing the line.

What the official pages say about vitamin D

This section collects what US and UK government pages say about vitamin D intakes, food sources, sunlight and what the supplement trials found. It is general information, not medical advice; talk to a doctor before taking supplements.

Source and what it says
SourceWhat it says
NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, Vitamin D (health professional fact sheet) (update date not confirmed on the page)RDA is 15 mcg (600 IU) for ages 1–70 and 20 mcg (800 IU) from 71; infants have an adequate intake of 10 mcg (400 IU). The upper limit is 100 mcg (4,000 IU) from age 9. Per serving: cod liver oil, 1 tablespoon, 34 mcg; farmed rainbow trout, 3 oz, 16.2 mcg; sockeye salmon, 3 oz, 14.2 mcg; UV-exposed mushrooms, half a cup, 9.2 mcg; 2% fortified milk, 1 cup, 2.9 mcg; one egg, 1.1 mcg.
NIH ODS, Vitamin D (consumer fact sheet) (updated Nov. 8, 2022)US milk is fortified with about 3 mcg (120 IU) per cup. Skin makes vitamin D from sunlight, but clouds, smog, age and darker skin reduce it, and it is not made through a window. Vitamin D3 may raise blood levels higher and for longer than D2.
USDA data via dietaryguidelines.gov, Food sources of vitamin D (undated; data from 2019)Lists amounts in IU only: rainbow trout 3 oz, 645; salmon, 383–570; canned light tuna, 231; 1% milk, 1 cup, 117; fortified orange juice, 1 cup, 100.
NIH ODS (above) and National Cancer Institute, Vitamin D and cancer (reviewed May 9, 2023)The large VITAL trial (25,871 people, 2,000 IU daily of D3, median 5.3 years) found no significant effect on cancer, heart disease, fractures or depression. NCI says most trials found no reduction in cancer risk, while a 10-trial analysis found a 13% reduction in cancer deaths. ODS says evidence on fractures and falls is inconsistent.
NHS, Vitamin D (reviewed Aug. 3, 2020; review overdue)10 micrograms (400 IU) a day for adults and children from age 1. Everyone should consider it in autumn and winter, and at-risk groups year-round. Safe upper limit 100 micrograms for adults, 50 for ages 1–10. UK cows’ milk is not fortified. It lists foods without amounts and says nothing on D2 versus D3.
US CDC, Benefits of spending time outdoors (June 17, 2026)Sunlight can make vitamin D, but this depends on skin tone, place, season and time of day. Extra sun beyond what the skin can make adds skin cancer risk without raising vitamin D. It gives no number of minutes.

What we could not confirm: the US and UK numbers are not the same kind of figure, since the US RDA of 15 mcg is a total-intake target while the NHS 10 mcg is a supplement recommendation, and upper limits for children also differ. On sunlight the agencies disagree: ODS says 5 to 30 minutes of midday sun may usually be enough, NCI says not to raise levels by adding sun because of skin cancer risk, and CDC gives no minutes. The ODS page’s own update date was not visible to us, and its IU values look rounded. We could not open USDA FoodData Central itself, so food amounts come from the ODS and dietaryguidelines.gov tables. Cancer-death findings are mixed across the sources, and the NHS page is past its review date.

What to do

Steps sorted by when they matter. Each one says how strong the evidence is: Measured Official advice Untested

Before

  • Get vitamin D from oily fish or fortified foods if you can. Three ounces of cooked trout is 16.2 µg and clears the day alone. Official advice see Sources
  • Ask a doctor about testing if you might be deficient. The trial that cut hip fractures by 43 per cent treated people who started deficient. Measured see Sources

What not to do

  • Do not take more than 4,000 IU a day off the shelf. It is the formal upper level, and falls data show harm signals at high blood levels. Official advice see Sources
  • Do not take cod liver oil casually, especially in pregnancy. One tablespoon carries 136 per cent of the vitamin A ceiling. Official advice see Sources
  • Do not expect a supplement to prevent fractures if your levels are already adequate. Three very large trials in mostly replete adults found essentially nothing. Measured see Sources

Not medical advice. Decisions about testing or supplementing belong with a doctor.

Who falls short on vitamin D: OECD countries by sex and age

What national surveys measured

Country and surveyTeens F / MAdults F / MOlder F / M
United StatesNHANES 2017–Mar 2020, USDA ARS · below EAR>97% / 95%14–18>97% / 95%31–50>97% / 89%71+
CanadaCCHS-Nutrition 2015, Health Canada · below EAR94% / 86%14–1898% / 97%31–5099% / 93%71+
GermanyNVS II 2005–07, Max Rubner-Institut · below recommended intake (higher cut-off)—91% / 82%14–80—

“—” means not published or too unreliable to publish. Surveys differ in year, age bands, reference values and method, so compare countries as a rough guide. The UK’s LRNI is a lower cut-off than the EAR, so its percentages run lower. Supplements are excluded.

Why countries, sexes and ages differ

  • The global model leaves vitamin D out, because the requirement can be met by sunlight rather than food. Food surveys miss skin synthesis, so nearly everyone looks short on food alone. (Passarelli et al., Lancet Glob Health 2024)
  • Above about 42°N the winter sun cannot make vitamin D in the skin for several months (November–February in Boston; October–March in Edmonton). (Rucker et al., CMAJ 2002)
  • Fortification differs: US milk is voluntarily fortified, Canadian milk and margarine by law, and Finland’s fortification of milk and spreads lifted average blood levels from 48 to 65 nmol/L between 2000 and 2011. (Jääskeläinen et al., AJCN 2017)
  • In Japan fish and shellfish supply 79% of dietary vitamin D, yet deficiency in adults still rose from 9% in July to 47% in November. (Nanri et al., J Epidemiol 2011)
  • Why the model and surveys disagree: the model infers each country’s intake spread from median intakes, applies one harmonised set of requirements, and leaves out supplements (and, for some nutrients, fortification); surveys use national reference values and methods. (Passarelli et al., AJCN 2022)

Sources: national surveys as linked in the table.

Questions people ask

How much vitamin D is in a tablespoon?

Only cod liver oil answers usefully: about 34 µg, or 1,360 IU, more than twice an adult’s daily requirement. Canned sockeye salmon gives about 3.15 µg a tablespoon, cooked trout 2.85 and cooked sockeye 2.51. Everything else is negligible per spoon.

So should I take cod liver oil?

Not on these numbers alone. The same tablespoon carries about 4,080 µg of preformed vitamin A against an adult upper level of 3,000 µg a day, so one spoonful supplies 227 per cent of the vitamin D requirement and 136 per cent of the vitamin A ceiling at once. That ceiling is set on birth defects, so the oil is not a product to take casually, and not in pregnancy without medical advice.

Can I get enough vitamin D from food alone?

Difficult without oily fish or fortified products. Three ounces of cooked trout gives 16.2 µg and clears the day alone; half a cup of UV-treated white mushrooms 9.2; a cup of fortified 2 per cent milk 2.9; two sardines in oil 1.2; one large egg 1.1. Average food intake is about a third of the RDA, so the oily-fish route is rarely taken. D2, the form in UV mushrooms and some fortified products, raises 25(OH)D less than D3 and holds it for a shorter time.

How much sun do I need?

No defensible number exists, which is why official guidance gives none. Latitude, season, time of day, cloud, smog, pigmentation, age, clothing and sunscreen each move it substantially, and UVB does not pass through glass. A fixed number of minutes is a figure calculated for someone else.

Is 5,000 IU a day safe?

It exceeds the upper level of 4,000 IU, the only threshold set formally. Frank toxicity sits far higher, but the fall data above the sufficiency range argue against treating the gap between 4,000 and toxic as empty. A dose prescribed after a measured deficiency is a different matter from one chosen off a shelf.

The short version

  • The skin makes it from UVB at 290–320 nm. Its established role is calcium absorption and bone mineralisation.
  • Per tablespoon, cod liver oil gives 34.0 µg, canned sockeye 3.15 and cooked trout 2.85. No other food comes close; cod flesh has 278 times less than the oil.
  • Food supplies about a third of the RDA in the average US diet, yet only 5 per cent of people are deficient. Skin makes up the difference, and no food table records it.
  • Deficiency causes rickets in children and osteomalacia in adults. Fortification from the 1930s made rickets rare, though it is returning in places.
  • Three large trials in mostly replete adults found essentially nothing. Chapuy 1992, in deficient nursing-home women also given calcium, cut hip fracture by 43 per cent. The difference is who was enrolled.
  • RDA 15 µg (600 IU), 20 µg (800 IU) over 70; upper level 100 µg (4,000 IU). Falls appear U-shaped, with harm signals above roughly 60 ng/mL.

This is a reference page, not clinical guidance. Vitamin D status depends on things no article can see — where you live, your skin, your age, what you absorb — and decisions about testing or supplementing belong with a doctor.

Further reading: Dawson-Hughes’ 2024 review is the shortest honest account of why the big trials and the old ones disagree, and Chapuy’s 1992 paper is worth reading beside it for how plainly it describes the population it treated.

Sources

  • NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, “Vitamin D”, fact sheet for health professionals. (RDA, UL and serum bands; intake 5.1 and 4.2 µg/day, 2015–2016; NHANES 2011–2014 5% deficient and 18% inadequate, with the group and age breakdowns; breastfed infants 20.5%; UVB 290–320 nm, SPF 8, glass; toxicity above 375 nmol/L; the per-serving food figures.)
  • USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy, vitamin D (D2 + D3) per 100 g. (Cod liver oil 173577, 250 µg; sockeye canned 173693, 21.0; trout farmed cooked 173718, 19.0; sockeye cooked 173692, 16.7; sockeye raw 173691, 14.1; herring cooked 175117, 5.4; Atlantic cod raw 171955, 0.9.)
  • Dawson-Hughes, B., “Effect of vitamin D on risk of falls and fractures: the contribution of recent mega-trials”, Metabolism Open, 2024, 100300. (Trial-by-trial account of VITAL, ViDA and D-Health; the U-shape; >60 ng/mL odds ratio 1.99, 1.2–3.3; D-Health BMI<25 subgroup 1.25, 1.09–1.43.)
  • LeBoff, M.S. et al., NEJM 387, 2022 (VITAL: 25,871, 2,000 IU/day, 5.3 years, baseline 30.2 ng/mL; fracture HR 0.98, 0.89–1.08; hip 1.01, 0.70–1.47); Waterhouse, M. et al., D-Health, 2023 (20,326, 60,000 IU monthly, 5.1 years; HR 0.94, hip 1.11, falls OR 1.02); Khaw, K.T. et al., ViDA, Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol 5(6), 2017 (5,108, 100,000 IU monthly, baseline 25.2 ng/mL; non-vertebral HR 1.19, 0.94–1.50).
  • Chapuy, M.C. et al., NEJM 327(23), 1992. (3,270 women, mean age 84.6, baseline 16 ng/mL, calcium intake 511 mg/day; 800 IU D3 plus 1.2 g calcium for 18 months; hip fracture −43%, other non-vertebral −32%.)
  • Appel, L.J. et al., STURDY, Ann Intern Med 174(2), 2021, and Sanders, K.M. et al., JAMA 303(18), 2010. (1,000 IU against 200 IU, more serious falls on the higher dose; 500,000 IU yearly, falls +15% and fractures +26%.)
  • Bolland, M.J., Grey, A. and Avenell, A., Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol 6(11), 2018. (Trial sequential analysis: further trials unlikely to change the null for fracture and falls.)
  • Institute of Medicine, Food and Nutrition Board, Dietary Reference Intakes for Calcium and Vitamin D, 2011. (The 50 nmol/L sufficiency line, set to cover 97.5 per cent of the population.)
  • NIH ODS; NIH ODS consumer; dietaryguidelines.gov; NCI; NHS; CDC.

Similar Posts